Anyone else enjoy a nip o' the barley?

  • This message board permanently closed on June 30th, 2020 at 4PM EDT and is no longer accepting new members.

Grandpa

Well-Known Member
Mar 2, 2014
9,724
53,642
Colorado
When I was young, I considered scotch an old man's drink. Well, now I'm old, and maybe I was right.

A couple decades ago, a wonderful friend, soccer teammate, decided to introduce me and a few others to the wonders of single malts. We met close to Robert Burns' birthday, and we've met once a year ever since, now for over 20 years. During that time, there have been kids, grandkids, divorces, remarriages, other invitees that just didn't quite fit in, and a couple near deaths. But the gathering remains.

We all get our food assignments (this is a dinner thing), and we all bring one single malt. We have to be sure to get a Highlands, a Lowlands, a Speyside, and an Islay, and one mystery scotch in the mix.

You'd think a bunch of guys getting together to drink would be raucous. Actually, it's pretty refined. Sometimes we have silly little mind games, we shoot pool, we read poetry (I was a hit one year when I found Robert Burns' "Cock Up Your Beaver," which of course was advice to a lad about wearing his headgear in a jaunty manner)(seriously!), and have a quiet even of camaraderie.

And the scotches. One of the guys confessed that it took him about three or four years to warm up to them, because up to that time, it was like sipping gasoline. But over the years, I've arrived at a few conclusions.

1) You can't go wrong with Macallan. Someone wants you to bring a single-malt scotch, you don't know what to do, grab a Macallan.

2) Lagavulin is sublime, and my favorite, but you have to like some bite of smoke and iodine. And apparently, I do.

3) Some "lighter" scotches of Knockandoo and Craggenmore are very, very pleasing.

4) Some scotches are overrated. There's nothing wrong with Glenlivet, but it doesn't live up to its price.

5) Some scotches punch above their weight. Highland Park and Balvenie Double Wood are great examples of this, and sure, go ahead and make up dirty jokes about the Balvenie. Hey, I already introduced the Burns poem.

Does anyone else like this stuff? Or is the newbie oldster standing along in this puddle of specialized yeast excrement? (And thank you, Kurt Vonnegut, for placing that term for alcohol in my head for the rest of my life.)
 

Tery

Say hello to my fishy buddy
Moderator
Apr 12, 2006
15,304
44,712
Bremerton, Washington, United States
You can't go wrong with Macallan. Someone wants you to bring a single-malt scotch, you don't know what to do, grab a Macallan.

Damn skippy! I don't have scotch often but when I do, it's the Macallan. Mostly because my "boss" and other writing idol - Neil Peart - drinks it exclusively. So I had to try it.

My Hubby likes Laphroiag from Scotland and Tullamore Dew from Ireland. But he'll deign to have a Macallan with me ;)

We went to the Whisky Museum in Edinburgh and got to taste the various kinds. I hadn't realized that there were differences (this was pre Macallan). But when you get to compare them in a tasting, you can really tell the difference.
 
Mar 12, 2010
6,538
29,004
Texas
When I was young, I considered scotch an old man's drink. Well, now I'm old, and maybe I was right.

A couple decades ago, a wonderful friend, soccer teammate, decided to introduce me and a few others to the wonders of single malts. We met close to Robert Burns' birthday, and we've met once a year ever since, now for over 20 years. During that time, there have been kids, grandkids, divorces, remarriages, other invitees that just didn't quite fit in, and a couple near deaths. But the gathering remains.

We all get our food assignments (this is a dinner thing), and we all bring one single malt. We have to be sure to get a Highlands, a Lowlands, a Speyside, and an Islay, and one mystery scotch in the mix.

You'd think a bunch of guys getting together to drink would be raucous. Actually, it's pretty refined. Sometimes we have silly little mind games, we shoot pool, we read poetry (I was a hit one year when I found Robert Burns' "Cock Up Your Beaver," which of course was advice to a lad about wearing his headgear in a jaunty manner)(seriously!), and have a quiet even of camaraderie.

And the scotches. One of the guys confessed that it took him about three or four years to warm up to them, because up to that time, it was like sipping gasoline. But over the years, I've arrived at a few conclusions.

1) You can't go wrong with Macallan. Someone wants you to bring a single-malt scotch, you don't know what to do, grab a Macallan.

2) Lagavulin is sublime, and my favorite, but you have to like some bite of smoke and iodine. And apparently, I do.

3) Some "lighter" scotches of Knockandoo and Craggenmore are very, very pleasing.

4) Some scotches are overrated. There's nothing wrong with Glenlivet, but it doesn't live up to its price.

5) Some scotches punch above their weight. Highland Park and Balvenie Double Wood are great examples of this, and sure, go ahead and make up dirty jokes about the Balvenie. Hey, I already introduced the Burns poem.

Does anyone else like this stuff? Or is the newbie oldster standing along in this puddle of specialized yeast excrement? (And thank you, Kurt Vonnegut, for placing that term for alcohol in my head for the rest of my life.)

You really are an amazing storyteller. Your posts are always so interesting! You could probably write about your trip to the grocery store and make it sound like an adventure lol

I'm a Texan so my preference for specialized yeast is a bottle of Lone Star. Was that descriptive term from Breakfast of Champions? Vonnegut really can change your vocabulary. Nobody knows what I'm talking about when I say, All is foma :)
 

Grandpa

Well-Known Member
Mar 2, 2014
9,724
53,642
Colorado
What a charming thread . . . "Cock Up Your Beaver" will have me googling!
Aye, Johnny lad!

My Hubby likes Laphroiag from Scotland and Tullamore Dew from Ireland. But he'll deign to have a Macallan with me ;)
Laphroig has a special place for me. It's the "heaviest" of the single malts that I've tried. Heavy on the seaweed and iodine, but I like strong tastes. I'll sip a Laphroig anytime. It's a great one.
You really are an amazing storyteller. Your posts are always so interesting! You could probably write about your trip to the grocery store and make it sound like an adventure lol
Thank you for making my day. A writer, even an ersatz/erstwhile one, just doesn't get higher praise than that.

I'm a Texan so my preference for specialized yeast is a bottle of Lone Star. Was that descriptive term from Breakfast of Champions? Vonnegut really can change your vocabulary. Nobody knows what I'm talking about when I say, All is foma :)
I believe it was. He talked about how yeast excrete alcohol, poisoning their own environment as they do. So now, if I think a little bit about alcohol, I think, "Yeast crap." Or some word like that.
 

GNTLGNT

The idiot is IN
Jun 15, 2007
87,651
358,754
62
Cambridge, Ohio
Meteor Sh!t for me!
creepshow5.jpg
 

DiO'Bolic

Not completely obtuse
Nov 14, 2013
22,864
129,998
Poconos, PA
I guess I’m an old guy, too.

About 15 years ago I became allergic to beer. A fate worse than death? I always say it’s proof there is a God and he’s got a wicked sense of humor.

Scotch has become my preferred devil’s brew. On my bar sits Johnnie Walker Black Label, Red Label, J&B, Clan MacGregor, and Inver House. I savor them all... the good, the bad and the ugly. And none gather dust. The Morrissey men have never been known as a refined lot. But I prefer my scotch on the rocks with lemon soda. A sin worthy of flogging to the aficionados, but I make no apologies or excuses. In the words of that celebrated musical ensemble KC & The Sunshine Band, "That's the way, uh-huh uh-huh, I like it, uh-huh, uh-huh."

My gatherings also include good food, plenty of drink, and a few games of 8-ball on the pool table. But the closest we come to poetry is listening to traditional Irish ballads that get the blood flowing and the feet a-tappin’

 
Last edited:

Mr Nobody

Well-Known Member
Jul 9, 2008
3,306
9,050
Walsall, England
I was given a bottle of Clynelish for an editing job. Bottled in 1992. It's in the cupboard between the Bell's (blended whisky/mixer stuff) and Jack Daniels, just along the way from a couple of bottles of Southern Comfort and one of Russian Standard vodka.
My gf's dad's the real whisky connoisseur. I've lost count of the number of single malts he's given me to try. Laphroaig and Glenmorangie are definitely two, though.
Is it an old man's drink? No, I don't think so. Either that or I've been an old man since 1991, when I was but 18. Back then, I used to neck it, neat, John Wayne/Clint Eastwood Western-stylee. Didn't much matter what it was.