The Doctor's Case. SKMB Reading and Discussion Group. 12.26.14

  • This message board permanently closed on June 30th, 2020 at 4PM EDT and is no longer accepting new members.

VultureLvr45

Well-Known Member
Mar 15, 2012
2,650
13,707
Maryland
I always wonder why SK had "Notes" on some of these short stories but not all of them. This was another one he didn't elaborate on. He was obviously influenced by the Holmes/Watson tales-I guess he thought some of these stories didn't need explaining...

This story flowed quickly to me. I think he may have 'channeled' Sir Arthur Conan Doyle to write it 8). You will know when you start to read the stories, a couple things about Sherlock and Watson. Watson is a medical doctor, Sherlock is a detective. They meetup daily and solve crimes. They are friends.
 

morgan

Well-Known Member
Jul 11, 2010
29,353
104,579
North Dakota
This story flowed quickly to me. I think he may have 'channeled' Sir Arthur Conan Doyle to write it 8). You will know when you start to read the stories, a couple things about Sherlock and Watson. Watson is a medical doctor, Sherlock is a detective. They meetup daily and solve crimes. They are friends.
It appears SK stayed true to the characters-at least from what I could tell from the little research I did after I read the story.
 

VultureLvr45

Well-Known Member
Mar 15, 2012
2,650
13,707
Maryland
What I didn't like, was the reference about the street boys teasing the starving dogs and the description of the battle-scarred cat. :big_tears:
I understand. Maybe he was using that type of imagery to let us know how horrible Lord Hull is. Drawing lines between how the mean kids treated the dogs to how the 'pussy will' was taking the hard earned reward away from his family. Lord Hull is in my top 10 SK Bad Guys list.
 

VultureLvr45

Well-Known Member
Mar 15, 2012
2,650
13,707
Maryland
It appears SK stayed true to the characters-at least from what I could tell from the little research I did after I read the story.
Very much so. I think you will enjoy the stories. They are short so you can read them on the bus, or maybe at a lunch break. Sherlock is independantly wealthy, makes money from solving crimes in all segments of society, and does drugs recreationally. He is brilliant and socially sought after, but would rather not be around people much. I think he likes watching them, but not interacting with them.
 

morgan

Well-Known Member
Jul 11, 2010
29,353
104,579
North Dakota
Lord Hull is in my top 10 SK Bad Guys list
Agreed! I know SK writes about these things for a reason-it definitely paints a picture. It's just my sensitivity, is all. He know that these "small" things can portray evil better than a three-eyed alien could, because truth is not only stranger than fiction, it is ultimately more horrifying.
 

morgan

Well-Known Member
Jul 11, 2010
29,353
104,579
North Dakota
"because truth is not only stranger than fiction, it is ultimately more horrifying." Well spoken, Luv.

Morgan, I know you are a little shy, but you do a great job making your thoughts known. I am really glad that you come to this group.

Are we on for Umney's Last Case next week?
Awwww shucks-thank you! :a11:
This group means everything to me and I am so grateful and honored to even be a part of it. Yes-we are on for next week! Thank you again, VL-this means the world to me.
 

VultureLvr45

Well-Known Member
Mar 15, 2012
2,650
13,707
Maryland
As far as the 'notes' in the back of the book, they remind me of really rich fudge or icing or perhaps an occasional naughty indulgence. We get them occasionally, they are special. We should be glad he puts any notes in it at all. For the people who lament because he gives us an extra story instead of notes, they need to get over it. It is his gift, and he is sharing it with the world the best that he can. I am a fan like you, Sweet Pea. I look forward to this too.
 

morgan

Well-Known Member
Jul 11, 2010
29,353
104,579
North Dakota
As far as the 'notes' in the back of the book, they remind me of really rich fudge or icing or perhaps an occasional naughty indulgence. We get them occasionally, they are special. We should be glad he puts any notes in it at all. For the people who lament because he gives us an extra story instead of notes, they need to get over it. It is his gift, and he is sharing it with the world the best that he can. I am a fan like you, Sweet Pea. I look forward to this too.
I agree-the "Notes" are an extra blessing! It is so frustrating to read the negative posts about SK not writing "Constant Reader" dedications in the beginning of some of his novels, etc. We need to remember the work in itself is a gift!
 

VultureLvr45

Well-Known Member
Mar 15, 2012
2,650
13,707
Maryland
I agree-the "Notes" are an extra blessing! It is so frustrating to read the negative posts about SK not writing "Constant Reader" dedications in the beginning of some of his novels, etc. We need to remember the work in itself is a gift!
Agreed. I think he does a great job welcoming the reader regardless if a "constant reader" or a "first timer."