UTD...just my $.02

  • This message board permanently closed on June 30th, 2020 at 4PM EDT and is no longer accepting new members.

Frizzlefries

Member
Feb 18, 2015
6
21
56
My first post...oh the pressure.

While the TV series is not my cuppa tea I'm certainly not here to bash on it, fans of it, or SK. I'm always glad when Mr King's hard work is appreciated to the point of offering up a movie / TV series version of anything he has created. I understand that changes are usually in order but the sheer number of changes made to the original "UTD" story are too much for me to truly enjoy the TV series. It's always been my belief that SK spends a great deal of time and effort (of which I'm truly grateful) in creating & developing his characters (esp for the bigger books) as well as the many story lines within a given tale. I get wrapped up in the story he's telling, thoroughly engrossed you might say, and finish the book completely satisfied. Then it gets transferred to the screen (big or small) and it feels like the floor has dropped out from under my feet...and not in a good way. What I always find myself thinking is: if Hollywood and the powers that be found this book to be so good, which it is, then why make so many sweeping changes? If it ain't broke (you know the rest). I think I would enjoy the series a lot more if they simply would have changed the names of all the characters. It's still a great basis for a multi-season TV series, as is evident by all the new material & characters that are constantly being added. Anyway, as you can probably tell I think it's a great book and I think I've exceeded my $.02 rant quota. I'll keep an open mind.

Cheers
 

danie

I am whatever you say I am.
Feb 26, 2008
9,760
60,662
60
Kentucky
If I really like a book, I tend not to watch it on the screen. As someone here recently wrote, "What is seen cannot be unseen," and the screen version messes up my mind version. Some exceptions (imo) are The Shawshank Redemption, The Green Mile, and Misery.
 

London Init Geezer

Well-Known Member
Mar 22, 2015
47
167
59
South London England
G
My first post...oh the pressure.

While the TV series is not my cuppa tea I'm certainly not here to bash on it, fans of it, or SK. I'm always glad when Mr King's hard work is appreciated to the point of offering up a movie / TV series version of anything he has created. I understand that changes are usually in order but the sheer number of changes made to the original "UTD" story are too much for me to truly enjoy the TV series. It's always been my belief that SK spends a great deal of time and effort (of which I'm truly grateful) in creating & developing his characters (esp for the bigger books) as well as the many story lines within a given tale. I get wrapped up in the story he's telling, thoroughly engrossed you might say, and finish the book completely satisfied. Then it gets transferred to the screen (big or small) and it feels like the floor has dropped out from under my feet...and not in a good way. What I always find myself thinking is: if Hollywood and the powers that be found this book to be so good, which it is, then why make so many sweeping changes? If it ain't broke (you know the rest). I think I would enjoy the series a lot more if they simply would have changed the names of all the characters. It's still a great basis for a multi-season TV series, as is evident by all the new material & characters that are constantly being added. Anyway, as you can probably tell I think it's a great book and I think I've exceeded my $.02 rant quota. I'll keep an open mind.

Cheers
Great first posting mate I see where your coming from but I just divorce the books from the films/TV adaptions and I must say I then thoroughly enjoy them.
Just finished season 1 and starting season 2 and finding it strangely addictive so alls good with me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: blunthead

HollyGolightly

Well-Known Member
Sep 6, 2013
9,660
74,320
54
Heart of the South
My first post...oh the pressure.

While the TV series is not my cuppa tea I'm certainly not here to bash on it, fans of it, or SK. I'm always glad when Mr King's hard work is appreciated to the point of offering up a movie / TV series version of anything he has created. I understand that changes are usually in order but the sheer number of changes made to the original "UTD" story are too much for me to truly enjoy the TV series. It's always been my belief that SK spends a great deal of time and effort (of which I'm truly grateful) in creating & developing his characters (esp for the bigger books) as well as the many story lines within a given tale. I get wrapped up in the story he's telling, thoroughly engrossed you might say, and finish the book completely satisfied. Then it gets transferred to the screen (big or small) and it feels like the floor has dropped out from under my feet...and not in a good way. What I always find myself thinking is: if Hollywood and the powers that be found this book to be so good, which it is, then why make so many sweeping changes? If it ain't broke (you know the rest). I think I would enjoy the series a lot more if they simply would have changed the names of all the characters. It's still a great basis for a multi-season TV series, as is evident by all the new material & characters that are constantly being added. Anyway, as you can probably tell I think it's a great book and I think I've exceeded my $.02 rant quota. I'll keep an open mind.

Cheers

Hi, H.I. - welcome!
 
  • Like
Reactions: blunthead