Your Latest Stephen King Related Purchase:

  • This message board permanently closed on June 30th, 2020 at 4PM EDT and is no longer accepting new members.

Mantor

Deema sidekick
Jul 31, 2014
177
579
57
Germany
I had my mom in Canada send me a DVD of Stanley Kubrick's The Shining because the full length version is still banned in Germany (1 hour 55 minutes intead of 2 hrs 25 I think it is) and, guess what, the DVD is high tech safety coded not to play in Germany. I could change the matrix positioning in my computer but then I thought why. If that is the law (for whatever messed up reason that nobody except me seems to notice or care about) that is the law and I am an upstanding citizen.

If anyone knows the reason I would be interested.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kingricefan

misery chastain loves co.

MORE Count Chocula please.....
Jul 31, 2011
2,642
15,099
51
Brewer,ME
Nice going Miss Morgan! It looks like a beautiful edition. Everyone is right, CD is notoriously slow but well worth it. I bought the limited IT and it's gorgeous. I also ordered a slipcase for Revival and that's going to take 12-14 weeks so if it takes that long on a slipcase imagine how long it takes for a book. I ordered their special Fangoria many months ago and still nothing. Much patience is required. lol.
 

Manxkitti

Well-Known Member
Sep 20, 2009
630
131
Walnut Creek, California, USA
I had my mom in Canada send me a DVD of Stanley Kubrick's The Shining because the full length version is still banned in Germany (1 hour 55 minutes intead of 2 hrs 25 I think it is) and, guess what, the DVD is high tech safety coded not to play in Germany. I could change the matrix positioning in my computer but then I thought why. If that is the law (for whatever messed up reason that nobody except me seems to notice or care about) that is the law and I am an upstanding citizen.

If anyone knows the reason I would be interested.

There are "Region 1" DVD's that are sold only in the US and Canada and will only play on DVD players sold in North America. There are "Region 2" DVD's that are only sold in other parts of the world. I believe the reason why, and I could be wrong on this, is because there are some movies that ARE banned in some European countries. Like the Hostel movies are banned altogether in the UK, I believe.

But, I could be wrong. :blush:
 

Kurben

The Fool on the Hill
Apr 12, 2014
9,682
65,192
59
sweden
There are "Region 1" DVD's that are sold only in the US and Canada and will only play on DVD players sold in North America. There are "Region 2" DVD's that are only sold in other parts of the world. I believe the reason why, and I could be wrong on this, is because there are some movies that ARE banned in some European countries. Like the Hostel movies are banned altogether in the UK, I believe.

But, I could be wrong. :blush:
I, personally, think it is so they could make even more money out of the buyers. But aren't there more then 2 regions,? thought there was at least three if not more geographical areas that each had its region.
 

Kurben

The Fool on the Hill
Apr 12, 2014
9,682
65,192
59
sweden
I believe so. Region 1 is USA/Canada and Region 2 is Europe. But I think you're right. It's to make more money.
How about Africa and South America? Where do they fit in. And are Australia and its neighbors linked to this regions? Same as Europe? And Asia? Just saying i don't know. Only know enough not to get an region one DVD because then i can only see it on my computer, not on my TV.
 

Officious Little Prick

Well-Known Member
Aug 28, 2014
129
443
51
Broken Arrow, OK
I had my mom in Canada send me a DVD of Stanley Kubrick's The Shining because the full length version is still banned in Germany (1 hour 55 minutes intead of 2 hrs 25 I think it is) and, guess what, the DVD is high tech safety coded not to play in Germany.

Go Blu-ray. The U.S. Blu-ray is region-free and will play anywhere in the world.
 

king family fan

Prolific member
Jul 19, 2010
33,133
117,741
south

Mantor

Deema sidekick
Jul 31, 2014
177
579
57
Germany
There are "Region 1" DVD's that are sold only in the US and Canada and will only play on DVD players sold in North America. There are "Region 2" DVD's that are only sold in other parts of the world. I believe the reason why, and I could be wrong on this, is because there are some movies that ARE banned in some European countries. Like the Hostel movies are banned altogether in the UK, I believe.

But, I could be wrong. :blush:
Thanks Manxkitti for that information. What I am wondering about is the reason that a half hour of the film is censored and still, to this day, so strongly enforced. Censored scenes were much of the 'Tony conversations' and Wendy with the lady doctor. Its been a while since I watched the censored German version...I was looking for the reason forthe censorship. It cannot be due to the length when they still do not offer a full length version on DVD or someplace and block DVDs from other countries. What is the advantage at all. It does not hurt. It does not raise joy. It does not make a statement or protect. There is more than meets the eye here, I would venture to say.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kingricefan

Mantor

Deema sidekick
Jul 31, 2014
177
579
57
Germany
Go Blu-ray. The U.S. Blu-ray is region-free and will play anywhere in the world.
The German folk poke fun at us Americans exposing so much violence on the film screen while making such a big deal about a little nipple or ass like anybody watching cares except those complaining it is all media hype and instigated gossip arranged by those involved to keep their names in the headlines and look like silly college sorority initiation rites. Now they do it too. Yes, maybe Blue Ray will save the day although I doubt it with a name like that.

What happens if Stephen King and the authorities finds out that people in Germany are now able to see the film in its entirety with blueray, all 2 hrs 24 minutes of it? What will the German government think and do about it then? Then there will be the debate of the rights to show it on German TV for the first time. But how? The edited version for Germany has been kept secret from the folk. Whenever I bring up the subject in Germany most forget that I mentioned it like five seconds afterwards. I'm beginning to think that leaving The Overlook Hotel intact in the film has come back to haunt us. And I bet it was that VW beetle Jack Torrance drove there. Whatever happened to it? The film left us hangin' there without concluding unlike the novel where The Overlook is brought down in exploding flames. Now that I think about it, Herbie the Love Bug could have been a cover until now.

I have seen the full length version a couple of times, at least, so lets just forget I ever brought up the subject. Too scary for me.
 

Officious Little Prick

Well-Known Member
Aug 28, 2014
129
443
51
Broken Arrow, OK
Mantor, this is not an issue of studio or governmental censorship or tampering. For private, yet hotly debated reasons, once THE SHINING migrated from U.S. theaters to European ones, Kubrick himself took the opportunity to cut the film down further. This may have been due to a) negative initial critical reviews in the U.S., b) a desire to "tighten up" the narrative, or c) as a way to pack more showings of the film into a given day (in other words, it may have been purely financially motivated). No one really knows Kubrick's thinking, but there is no ban on the film in either edit; ergo, both the long U.S. cut and the short UK/German one are region-free across the world on Blu-ray. Region coding, for both Blu-rays and DVDs, is in place to prevent countries foreign to the one that made a given film from seeing it before it's legitimate theatrical release. As such, it's a pretty foolish practice for catalog releases (i.e. those older than five years), but it's still a common one. Fortunately, Warner Bros. did right by the Blu-ray release and made it where everyone in the world can enjoy it. I assure you, you'll be in violation of no laws if you import the U.S. Blu-ray over there.
 

Mantor

Deema sidekick
Jul 31, 2014
177
579
57
Germany
Mantor, this is not an issue of studio or governmental censorship or tampering. For private, yet hotly debated reasons, once THE SHINING migrated from U.S. theaters to European ones, Kubrick himself took the opportunity to cut the film down further. This may have been due to a) negative initial critical reviews in the U.S., b) a desire to "tighten up" the narrative, or c) as a way to pack more showings of the film into a given day (in other words, it may have been purely financially motivated). No one really knows Kubrick's thinking, but there is no ban on the film in either edit; ergo, both the long U.S. cut and the short UK/German one are region-free across the world on Blu-ray. Region coding, for both Blu-rays and DVDs, is in place to prevent countries foreign to the one that made a given film from seeing it before it's legitimate theatrical release. As such, it's a pretty foolish practice for catalog releases (i.e. those older than five years), but it's still a common one. Fortunately, Warner Bros. did right by the Blu-ray release and made it where everyone in the world can enjoy it. I assure you, you'll be in violation of no laws if you import the U.S. Blu-ray over there.
I told you all. You forgot about the VW beetle. Forgot the most dangerous part of my story. Call an exorcist.
 

Manxkitti

Well-Known Member
Sep 20, 2009
630
131
Walnut Creek, California, USA
Thanks Manxkitti for that information. What I am wondering about is the reason that a half hour of the film is censored and still, to this day, so strongly enforced. Censored scenes were much of the 'Tony conversations' and Wendy with the lady doctor. Its been a while since I watched the censored German version...I was looking for the reason forthe censorship. It cannot be due to the length when they still do not offer a full length version on DVD or someplace and block DVDs from other countries. What is the advantage at all. It does not hurt. It does not raise joy. It does not make a statement or protect. There is more than meets the eye here, I would venture to say.

You're welcome. I believe it's due to the violence as well. Movies put out by US studios are pretty violent.
 

Blake

Deleted User
Feb 18, 2013
4,191
17,479
Good deal - I think up here in Canada it is going for about 22 - 25 bucks at the store.
I am Mr. Cranky, formally 'Gus', 'Mark', or Triple H. I feel better that those guys at the pub can't check out what I'm saying on here. One of them is continually 'texting' people, wanting to know other people's business I presume. I think you sent me a photograph of yourself and your husband, so in a couple of days I'll take a picture of myself (not in my budgie smugglers) and show you what I look like.