possible LOTR misquote?

  • This message board permanently closed on June 30th, 2020 at 4PM EDT and is no longer accepting new members.

Mar 5, 2019
7
27
27
Texas
i’m reading the stand for the first time, & i’m about 300 pages in, & at this point rita & larry have just packed their bags & are preparing to leave the city. i’m a huge LOTR fan & i know stephen king loves tolkien too, so this part excited me but confused me all at once. i know it’s probably not a big deal at alllll i just was curious if it was simply a mistake or if it was intentional. here’s the quote i’m talking about: “the beginning of a journey,” she said, & then so softly he wasn’t sure he’d heard her correctly: “the way leads ever on...” “what?” “it’s a line from Tolkien,” she said, “The Lord of the Rings. i’ve always thought of it as sort of a gateway to adventure.” so i googled just to make sure i wasn’t forgetting a line that was slightly different & couldn’t find anything, but i know the line in the song is “the road goes ever on”. is it possible it was intentionally misquoted because of the line about larry possibly mishearing her? that seems like an unnecessary thing to do, though. it just seems odd to me that something so known would be mistakenly misquoted by king. wouldn’t that be something you double check before writing it in off the top of your head? just wanted to know if anyone out there had any insight to this or if i’m just being way too nitpicky & it’s simply a mistake! (yes, i’m aware how nerdy & obnoxious this post probably is lol)
 

Neesy

#1 fan (Annie Wilkes cousin) 1st cousin Mom's side
May 24, 2012
61,289
239,271
Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
it just seems odd to me that something so known would be mistakenly misquoted by king. wouldn’t that be something you double check before writing it in off the top of your head?
I guess you could just call it "artistic license" - it's just a good story so why should he micro-analyse every word? I would think you'd spend all your time making sure you got a reference correct and it would interrupt the flow of writing.

Not being adversarial or belligerent here (it's just my opinion of why a LOTR quote might be slightly off).

Plus - considering it was published in 1978, King was younger then and not quite as famous as he is today. He's only human and makes mistakes just like everyone else.


_bringonthenight_

wolf and raven.jpg
 

GNTLGNT

The idiot is IN
Jun 15, 2007
87,651
358,754
62
Cambridge, Ohio
i’m reading the stand for the first time, & i’m about 300 pages in, & at this point rita & larry have just packed their bags & are preparing to leave the city. i’m a huge LOTR fan & i know stephen king loves tolkien too, so this part excited me but confused me all at once. i know it’s probably not a big deal at alllll i just was curious if it was simply a mistake or if it was intentional. here’s the quote i’m talking about: “the beginning of a journey,” she said, & then so softly he wasn’t sure he’d heard her correctly: “the way leads ever on...” “what?” “it’s a line from Tolkien,” she said, “The Lord of the Rings. i’ve always thought of it as sort of a gateway to adventure.” so i googled just to make sure i wasn’t forgetting a line that was slightly different & couldn’t find anything, but i know the line in the song is “the road goes ever on”. is it possible it was intentionally misquoted because of the line about larry possibly mishearing her? that seems like an unnecessary thing to do, though. it just seems odd to me that something so known would be mistakenly misquoted by king. wouldn’t that be something you double check before writing it in off the top of your head? just wanted to know if anyone out there had any insight to this or if i’m just being way too nitpicky & it’s simply a mistake! (yes, i’m aware how nerdy & obnoxious this post probably is lol)
...I bid you a warm welcome, and would simply say he kept the spirit of the quote, if not the accuracy......