This book should definitely either be in the Novels or the Novellas section.
PS. This is my first post! TAK!
PS. This is my first post! TAK!
This message board permanently closed on June 30th, 2020 at 4PM EDT and is no longer accepting new members.
Welcome to the Board!This book should definitely either be in the Novels or the Novellas section.
PS. This is my first post! TAK!
I can see why you might think that, but those are novels, not novellas, and belong in the novels section just as Sleeping Beauties does.Why would a novella partially written by someone else be here? By that logic The Talisman and Black House would be here.
So why is this miscellaneous, but The Plant, an actual unfinished story, is in Novels?I can see why you might think that, but those are novels, not novellas, and belong in the novels section just as Sleeping Beauties does.
....it was originally to BE a novel......wow......So why is this miscellaneous, but The Plant, an actual unfinished story, is in Novels?
But it wasn't, so it's unfinished.....it was originally to BE a novel......wow......
...point is, that's why it's listed under "Novels" albeit an unfinished one.....But it wasn't, so it's unfinished.
Nope, another 45 minutes left to go!Is it 4 yet?
The Plant is considered an "unfinished" Novel.But it wasn't, so it's unfinished.
almostIs it 4 yet?
But the word "unfinished" means it should be here.The Plant is considered an "unfinished" Novel.
Word count usually determines if short story, novella, or novel. I believe, The Plant, falls into the novel framework.
If you read through the other threads in that forum, you'll find discussions about a LOT of other stories, etc. so don't get so hung up on the "unfinished" part of the description. That is just one of the categories we considered when creating the Miscellaneous Works forum.But the word "unfinished" means it should be here.
And that still leaves no reason why Gwendy's Button Box is here, as it is not unfinished.
Right after retirement, right?I could be misremembering but I think when we first redesigned this version of the site, we did not have the Miscellaneous Works section at all and that was added after The Plant had been put into the Novels area. Yes, it could probably be moved over to Miscellaneous now that we have that section and I'll add it to the list of things to update.
Could be.Right after retirement, right?