SPOILERS --My long-winded thoughts after rereading Stephen King's It (spoilers)

  • This message board permanently closed on June 30th, 2020 at 4PM EDT and is no longer accepting new members.

ThomasWinter

Member
Jun 2, 2017
15
49
44
Stephen King's It was the first King book that I had ever read (a little over 10 years ago), which led me on a path to reading many of his books in a three or four year span. With the new movie coming out, I decided to reread the book that started it all. After finishing a second time, I have been searching for all kinds of thoughts from others (which led me to many podcasts and eventually to this board) on what I found to be the most heart-wrenching thing that happened: the memory loss. Unfortunately, I have only seen passing mention of the sadness of it with minor exploration done on the theme.

After the final battle and Mike's making his last journal entries, writing about his final conversations with everyone and how they're all (even him) now forgetting about each other again, I was reduced to tears at his last words:

I loved you guys, you know.
I loved you so much.


Even now there's a little tug at the heart string just reading the words and thinking about their time together. His final conversation with Richie in particular (them not remembering Stan's last name or what ailment Eddie had) was just so deeply frustrating and sad at the same time. I was screaming in my head, "No, don't away their memories of each other! You can't!"

I'd assume there is some deep psychological meaning behind it about forgetting childhood, but it got to me in another way. While reading this book the first time, I don't remember the memory loss aspect hitting me as hard emotionally, but then during the reread, it was like I was called up by Mike Hanlon himself.

After going just 10 years of not reading It, I had just about forgotten EVERYTHING. Prior to the reread, if you offered me up a million dollars to name all of the Losers Club, I would not be a million dollars richer afterwards. I thought It was an absolutely amazing book after reading it the first time. King's words were put together so well on the 1,000+ pages that I felt like I was a citizen of Derry, Maine and a part of the Losers Club, and there's a euphoric feeling I had during and immediately after the read.

Then I forgot about everything.

Even now the memories and feelings are fading. All that emotional connection I had is disappearing, and it deeply saddens me. Maybe in another 10 years I'll get that imaginary call from Mike to reread It and allow the memories to slowly return.

That's all.
 

recitador

Speed Reader
Sep 3, 2016
1,750
8,264
41
he hit me even earlier with the line about It finally being dead and all it cost them was their friendship and stan and eddie's lives. not really reduced to tears but it might've gotten a little dusty suddenly. it's a roller coaster of a book
 

not_nadine

Comfortably Roont
Nov 19, 2011
29,655
139,785
Behind you
I just did a re-read myself. Hit me too when they started forgetting again. C'mon! don't do this, Stephen King. And he did - because he can.
And he probably smiled while typing it out.
He got me all teary at the ending.

Richie almost not answering the phone.... Mike's voice.


Welcome to the boards. Lovely first post.
 
Last edited:

Steve in WI

Active Member
Sep 17, 2017
38
172
39
Hope it's okay to resurrect an old thread; I agree completely. To the extent that I can remember, this is what stuck with me the most after I read the story for the first time as a young teen. The idea of forgetting as an inevitability (in particular, when Mike believes that he could recopy his fading notes over and over and that they would still eventually fade away) really got to me. It's bad enough - if perhaps understandable - that the kids go their separate ways after 1958 and forget each other; it is absolutely chilling that after getting back together and remembering everything in 1985, they are still destined to forget it all over again.

As an adult now, looking back on my childhood 20 years and longer ago, it amazes me how much I've forgotten.
 

GNTLGNT

The idiot is IN
Jun 15, 2007
87,651
358,754
62
Cambridge, Ohio
Hope it's okay to resurrect an old thread; I agree completely. To the extent that I can remember, this is what stuck with me the most after I read the story for the first time as a young teen. The idea of forgetting as an inevitability (in particular, when Mike believes that he could recopy his fading notes over and over and that they would still eventually fade away) really got to me. It's bad enough - if perhaps understandable - that the kids go their separate ways after 1958 and forget each other; it is absolutely chilling that after getting back together and remembering everything in 1985, they are still destined to forget it all over again.

As an adult now, looking back on my childhood 20 years and longer ago, it amazes me how much I've forgotten.
....I know, it's as if a valued part of you has been expunged......
 

Steffen

Well-Known Member
Aug 9, 2015
2,233
12,800
recitador is quite right when he calls this book an emotional roller-coaster. Out of all King's stories, this one connected with me even stronger than The Body. I was just a couple of years older than the kids when it first came out. I listened to the audio-book earlier this year, just a couple of years older than the adults. I know what it's like to lose friends I grew up with, and when I remember them now, it's just bits and pieces. But that's The King for you: gotta take the bitter with the sweet, just like in real life.
 
Mar 9, 2018
9
41
39
Stephen King's It was the first King book that I had ever read (a little over 10 years ago), which led me on a path to reading many of his books in a three or four year span. With the new movie coming out, I decided to reread the book that started it all. After finishing a second time, I have been searching for all kinds of thoughts from others (which led me to many podcasts and eventually to this board) on what I found to be the most heart-wrenching thing that happened: the memory loss. Unfortunately, I have only seen passing mention of the sadness of it with minor exploration done on the theme.

After the final battle and Mike's making his last journal entries, writing about his final conversations with everyone and how they're all (even him) now forgetting about each other again, I was reduced to tears at his last words:

I loved you guys, you know.
I loved you so much.


Even now there's a little tug at the heart string just reading the words and thinking about their time together. His final conversation with Richie in particular (them not remembering Stan's last name or what ailment Eddie had) was just so deeply frustrating and sad at the same time. I was screaming in my head, "No, don't away their memories of each other! You can't!"

I'd assume there is some deep psychological meaning behind it about forgetting childhood, but it got to me in another way. While reading this book the first time, I don't remember the memory loss aspect hitting me as hard emotionally, but then during the reread, it was like I was called up by Mike Hanlon himself.

After going just 10 years of not reading It, I had just about forgotten EVERYTHING. Prior to the reread, if you offered me up a million dollars to name all of the Losers Club, I would not be a million dollars richer afterwards. I thought It was an absolutely amazing book after reading it the first time. King's words were put together so well on the 1,000+ pages that I felt like I was a citizen of Derry, Maine and a part of the Losers Club, and there's a euphoric feeling I had during and immediately after the read.

Then I forgot about everything.

Even now the memories and feelings are fading. All that emotional connection I had is disappearing, and it deeply saddens me. Maybe in another 10 years I'll get that imaginary call from Mike to reread It and allow the memories to slowly return.

That's all.
could not have put it better myself. the feelings i have (just finished the book on monday 4 days ago) are exactly like you described. glad i came here to have the feels with y'all.