This message board permanently closed on June 30th, 2020 at 4PM EDT and is no longer accepting new members.
I wondered the same thing. Each member of the Loser's Club had at least one flaw (or perceived flaw) that made them "losers"...stuttering was Bill's. It was very important to the book and even the climax. Maybe he does stutter in the new film or the kid actor wasn't able to pull off a stutter convincingly. I did notice Eddie with his inhaler. I hope they use some '80s music in this, too, btw.
Barbara Muschietti herself cleared this issue up. Someone asked the same thing on her Instagram page and she said "of course he does. Stuttering Bill!" so yay! They wanted to save some surprises I guess.
I'm new here. Just started reading IT for the first time so my opinion probably doesn't matter as much and it's certainly not as informed as most of you so correct me wherever I'm wrong as I'm bound to be.
I'm mixed on the trailer for a few reasons.
1. The tone of it feels much more like a modern horror movie. Especially with Pennywise rushing Bill like that. It just doesn't seem like the more tormenting and toying aspects of him. The design of him further cements this, he no longer looks like an ordinary but off clown he seems like he's a monster from square one. Even his smiling self still has a pure evil look whereas Tim Curry knew how to make being happy scary.
A good example is this comparison -
The actor playing the new Pennywise keeps tilting his head down and it's obviously done to make him look more evil. While Tim Curry doesn't rely on that because just seeing Pennywise in random locations as a clown is scary naturally. Being subtle to me is always far more effective.
2. The music - Oh man do I miss the TV series theme. I don't know if the music in the trailer is actually from the movie but again it did nothing for me. It wasn't haunting, it wasn't dread inducing.....the original IT tv series theme was such a huge part to making Derry feel off and like a character itself. The music in this trailer just sounded like music you could have inserted into any horror movie trailer.
3. Back to Pennywise. Does anyone think casting someone young was the wrong idea? It just looks.....wrong to me again. It feels weird that he's a young looking clown.
4. I still wish they went with the 50's, as much as I love the 80's the 50's era was a huge part of the spirit to the story. Even as someone who hasn't even finished reading it you can just tell how essential it is to Derry. While the 80's works as well, to this day I have no clue why they had to make that change. There's plenty of period piece movies that work.
Anyone have thoughts on my points whether you agree or disagree..I'd love to be reassured or even explain why certain things could work well. I want to love this movie, I want it to succeed.
As I said, many of you who have actually read the novel will have more insight to what they're doing than me. I did hear they were using more from the book which makes me happy as well. I guess I'm just not excited about the new look of Pennywise. I'm not saying the book described him or old or not, I just thought the older man dressed as a clown was a creepier aspect when dealing with children. It's a creepy mix of an older guy dressed as a clown messing with kids. Compared to a younger looking clown... Personal preference for sure I'm just curious why they went younger. He may nail the performance though for all I know!
The TV series got huge ratings when it first aired. I think there's a lot of fans of "IT". 1408 made over 132 million on a similar budget. I can't picture IT doing worse.
Which I probably would have no problem with if the design didn't already look like an evil monster in default clown mode. I've yet to see a picture of the new Pennywise where he looks the least bit inviting at all, even when he smiles he looks pure evil. They struck an incredible balance with the old pennywise.
Which I probably would have no problem with if the design didn't already look like an evil monster in default clown mode. I've yet to see a picture of the new Pennywise where he looks the least bit inviting at all, even when he smiles he looks pure evil. They struck an incredible balance with the old pennywise.
Tim Curry's looked more like your average clown but you knew something was off about him. The new pennywise doesn't look like your average clown at all. I wish there was more of a middle ground between the two.
You know though, people said the same about Heath Ledgar and it turned out quite excellent. Just gotta wait and see.
What's done is done. I'll have to live with this new take
Sorry, I'm probably not clear in what I'm saying. The costume's color scheme IS very accurate to the book but that wasn't my complaint. It was the costume looking ancient and his face, I don't believe the book comments on it looking like it was from a different time period entirely did it? I remember fairly recent comparisons named in the book like Bozo the clown which would be more in line with the tv series in terms of "STYLE" not color. To be fair though I think your reasoning for why his costume looks old is completely sound and an interesting and logical take of it. The costume itself looks cool it just looks old, it's the face that I'm not sold on. No kid would be lured to a clown that looked that much like a monster even when he smiles
It wasn't just the kids that sensed something was 'off' about Pennywise, there were a couple of adults who said the same thing. One of them was the boyfriend of the man who was thrown off of the bridge in Derry- he said he saw a clown under the bridge when the gay bashing was happening and knew something was wrong with it just from a not-too-near glimpse. There were other adults who saw Pennywise and knew to stay away.
Sorry, I'm probably not clear in what I'm saying. The costume's color scheme IS very accurate to the book but that wasn't my complaint. It was the costume looking ancient and his face, I don't believe the book comments on it looking like it was from a different time period entirely did it? I remember fairly recent comparisons named in the book like Bozo the clown which would be more in line with the tv series in terms of "STYLE" not color. To be fair though I think your reasoning for why his costume looks old is completely sound and an interesting and logical take of it. The costume itself looks cool it just looks old, it's the face that I'm not sold on. No kid would be lured to a clown that looked that much like a monster even when he smiles
It's helpful when you all point to the book because like I admitted in my first post I haven't even finished reading it, so any clarifications on things would be greatly appreciated. I may be basing most of my opinions on the TV series and despite my lack of knowledge on the book I still would want it to follow the book above all. So if they're doing that then great! I just won't be aware of it till I finish.
