LOVED this book ~ except for one thing ~

Discussion in 'Mr. Mercedes' started by scar1ett, Jun 9, 2014.

  1. scar1ett

    scar1ett New Member

    ~ I really don't like it when an exact location isn't given in a book. I guess I'm 'old school' and really love the ones that take place in Maine. No, I'm not from Maine ~ not even an American. ;) But, I'm ok with the location being 'any place' ~ as long as it's 'some place'. Just my opinion.

    Still ~ really love the story and, of course, couldn't put the book down. :) This will make a fantastic movie!
     
    Autumn Gust, Neesy, jchanic and 3 others like this.
  2. doowopgirl

    doowopgirl very avid fan

    Welcome. I kind of like when a location isn't specifed because then people can't come on and complain you got the geographt wrong or something.
     
  3. scar1ett

    scar1ett New Member

    Different strokes ~ ~ ~
     
  4. Chazel1972

    Chazel1972 Well-Known Member

    I am from the Midwest (med to large sized town). I would have liked a location too. I thought it being set a few years back was weird too, but I think he was playing up the recession No?
     
    Autumn Gust, morgan, Neesy and 3 others like this.
  5. mjs9153

    mjs9153 Guest

    you know I've been wondering about that and the lack of detail and places.. And what I was thinking was maybe with that and some of the errors and inconsistencies that were noticed that may be the story was taking place on some other level of the tower.. In other words, not in our presence,not our world..
     
  6. GNTLGNT

    GNTLGNT Idiot in Situ and Unholy Devourer of Cookies

    ...the Indians are prominently featured and a reference made to being near the locale of that particular MLB club...other than that, I kinda grooved on the lack of GPS specific whereabouts...
     
  7. Jimpy

    Jimpy Well-Known Member

    The book mentions that the closest major league team in the Cleveland Indians, this makes it take place in Ohio due to the presence of Detroit, Pittsburg and Cincinnati. The presence of the Mingo Auditorium would kind of make it seem like it could be near Steubenville or Urbana. However, Steubenville would be closer to Pittsburg and Urbana to Cincinnati. Then again the Mingo Indians ranged all over Ohio at one point or another. The book takes place in Ohio, Columbus or north, east of Sandusky and west of Youngstown. Probably near The fictional town of Wentworth, home of The Regulators.
     
  8. Chris_Ferox

    Chris_Ferox Member

    they are right on the lake so it has to be Cleveland
     
  9. Jimpy

    Jimpy Well-Known Member

    Mr Mercades says the Indians are the closest team. In the right direction, due south or southwest, you can be 100-120 miles from Lake Erie and still have them as the closest team.
     
  10. Moderator

    Moderator Ms. Mod Administrator

    He was being purposely ambiguous in the geographical location, other than that it was Ohio.
     
    skimom2, Neesy, morgan and 8 others like this.
  11. GNTLGNT

    GNTLGNT Idiot in Situ and Unholy Devourer of Cookies

    ...I could smell the ambiguity, or maybe that's Lake Erie....:biggrin-new:
     
    Neesy, morgan, Spideyman and 4 others like this.
  12. jchanic

    jchanic Well-Known Member

    As a Clevelander, the story just did not ring true if it were in Cleveland. Just my opinion.

    John
     
    Autumn Gust, morgan, GNTLGNT and 3 others like this.
  13. Bev Vincent

    Bev Vincent Well-Known Member

    Parts of Rose Madder also took place in a fictional Great Lakes city. Maybe even the same one?
     
    skimom2, Neesy, Autumn Gust and 4 others like this.
  14. GNTLGNT

    GNTLGNT Idiot in Situ and Unholy Devourer of Cookies

    ...that's why the locale seemed familiar!....
     
    Neesy, Autumn Gust and Spideyman like this.
  15. GNTLGNT

    GNTLGNT Idiot in Situ and Unholy Devourer of Cookies

    ...it just coz the Cuyahoga wasn't on fire....:star:
     
    Autumn Gust and mjs9153 like this.
  16. Chris_Ferox

    Chris_Ferox Member

    IMO not naming it Cleveland is the way out of using the location without having it "ring true". likely a better idea than, e.g. Buick 8, where he named the West PA locations but (as here) had no legit sense of the character of the place, might as well have stuck with Maine. so I think he was sidestepping that issue here by not naming Cleveland
     
    Autumn Gust, GNTLGNT and Jimpy like this.
  17. Moderator

    Moderator Ms. Mod Administrator

    Not being specific does help maintain the "flow" when writing so that it's not as important to make sure you've got every little detail right. He may have been thinking about keeping the nit-picking about how he got it wrong to a minimum if he had used a specific spot. Seems like the guy just can't win as he gets the nit-picking no matter what.
     
    rocker1972, Neesy, danie and 7 others like this.
  18. mjs9153

    mjs9153 Guest

    [​IMG]
     
  19. GNTLGNT

    GNTLGNT Idiot in Situ and Unholy Devourer of Cookies

    [​IMG]
     
    ginapenn, Neesy, Autumn Gust and 6 others like this.
  20. Sigmund

    Sigmund Well-Known Member

    Hi.

    I just finished Mr. Mercedes and I loved it.

    I guess I'm not as intelligent or observant as other members. I just sit back, relax, read the story and enjoy.

    I'm simple.

    Peace.
     

Share This Page

Prepare for Revival