A Dog's Purpose

  • This message board permanently closed on June 30th, 2020 at 4PM EDT and is no longer accepting new members.

CoriSCapnSkip

Well-Known Member
Jan 16, 2015
1,735
7,765
61
Posted this review on the official Ray Bradbury Message Board Forums so it's geared to that but decided not to change it.

After checking on the controversy over possible mistreatment of an animal during the filming of A Dog's Purpose, http://www.adogspurposemovie.com I decided the incident, although a genuine occurrence (or rather several occurrences edited together to give the effect that they happened at the same time) which should have been handled differently, was blown out of proportion by someone with an agenda and that I could in good conscience view it.

During this film I experienced many Bradburyesque moments. Idyllic small town and rural American scenes unfolded on shady streets and at a country carnival. Shots of a dog bounding through wheat fields gave me a real Dandelion Wine feeling. In several places it was reminiscent of "The Emissary," and if one scene in particular did not recall that story to the viewer, that viewer is not a genuine Ray Bradbury reader.

Parts of the story also depict urban settings and characters from various backgrounds and walks of life, calling to mind Bradbury's extensive and colorful cast of characters. The use of music throughout the film, particularly popular music to set different time periods, was nothing short of brilliant, and the use of TV show clips and other aspects of American life are also skillfully employed.

The Bradbury story most specific to the movie's theme is "The Reincarnate," but many touches reminiscent of his best work and the film's emotional impact will overwhelm Bradbury fans and animal lovers alike. This film is utterly remarkable in that despite some distressing scenes, it is absolutely suitable for viewers of all ages, an unheard-of rarity these days. My friend brought her three-year-old granddaughter. By all means see this, take your family, and bring lots of tissues!
 

Neesy

#1 fan (Annie Wilkes cousin) 1st cousin Mom's side
May 24, 2012
61,289
239,271
Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
i've watched half of this movie, just passed the point in question, and found it quite a moving story. the neglected scene was quite sad, but it looks like a great movie -
dogs-purpose-poster02.jpg


Are there any pugs in it? So far I have only read the book - the movie has now moved to the "cheap theatres" here in my city
 

SHEEMIEE

Well-Known Member
Nov 15, 2010
1,315
5,574
dogs-purpose-poster02.jpg


Are there any pugs in it? So far I have only read the book - the movie has now moved to the "cheap theatres" here in my city

no
pugs


really annoyed. the movie was good, but i knew exactly was was coming because of the fecking trailer again. Once more we are treated to the very last scene- the very very last scene in the movie! so you know exactly how it ends. unbelievable. why do they do that?
 

Steffen

Well-Known Member
Aug 9, 2015
2,233
12,800
It's been over a year since I lost my favourite dog and I can't bring myself to watch this film. I know that makes me sound like a real wuss, but I looked at that trailer and it reminded me so much of my friendship with my own dog. Haven't worked up the courage to go see it yet.
 

Spideyman

Uber Member
Jul 10, 2006
46,336
195,472
79
Just north of Duma Key
It's been over a year since I lost my favourite dog and I can't bring myself to watch this film. I know that makes me sound like a real wuss, but I looked at that trailer and it reminded me so much of my friendship with my own dog. Haven't worked up the courage to go see it yet.
As Tery said, not a wuss. Cried through the book/ can't watch the movie.
 

Tery

Say hello to my fishy buddy
Moderator
Apr 12, 2006
15,304
44,712
Bremerton, Washington, United States
There's a short story I found when I was a teen, about a kitten. I read it as part of a talent thing when I was going to the LDS church (yes, I did!). I paired it with a poem from Paul Gallico's Honorable Cat (if you haven't read that, you should). The poem went over well but the story, not so much. This was because of its representation of Heaven.

The kitten, you see, was a stray and a "reprobate" on his way home from doing reprobate things early in the morning, saw it and, on a whim, picked it up along with a bottle of milk from a nearby stoop (yes, they used to deliver milk!). He takes the kitten up to his room and feeds it the milk. Moments later, a policeman comes and arrests him for stealing the milk. He goes to jail, cursing the kitten. The kitten goes looking for him and is hit by a car (I recall the fragment; "... and a truck came around the corner, very fast...). Years later, when the criminal dies, he goes to Heaven's gates. Peter tells him that if one soul can vouch for him, he won't go to Hell because how could a soul in Heaven be truly happy if they know a loved one is suffering in Hell? They wait... OMG, I'm getting teary writing this... and, just as the man is turning to go, the kitten comes marching to the gate, "his tail held high like a banner." To the kitten, that reprobate was a savior. So, because of one good deed, even a reprobate can be saved.

The bold part is what got me in trouble. I heard an audible gasp when I read it and smirked a little inside. Let them chew on that one for a bit. I left the Mormons soon after that. But I've always remembered that story and cannot for the life of me find it now. Maybe it rings a bell for someone?
 

Neesy

#1 fan (Annie Wilkes cousin) 1st cousin Mom's side
May 24, 2012
61,289
239,271
Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
There's a short story I found when I was a teen, about a kitten. I read it as part of a talent thing when I was going to the LDS church (yes, I did!). I paired it with a poem from Paul Gallico's Honorable Cat (if you haven't read that, you should). The poem went over well but the story, not so much. This was because of its representation of Heaven.

The kitten, you see, was a stray and a "reprobate" on his way home from doing reprobate things early in the morning, saw it and, on a whim, picked it up along with a bottle of milk from a nearby stoop (yes, they used to deliver milk!). He takes the kitten up to his room and feeds it the milk. Moments later, a policeman comes and arrests him for stealing the milk. He goes to jail, cursing the kitten. The kitten goes looking for him and is hit by a car (I recall the fragment; "... and a truck came around the corner, very fast...). Years later, when the criminal dies, he goes to Heaven's gates. Peter tells him that if one soul can vouch for him, he won't go to Hell because how could a soul in Heaven be truly happy if they know a loved one is suffering in Hell? They wait... OMG, I'm getting teary writing this... and, just as the man is turning to go, the kitten comes marching to the gate, "his tail held high like a banner." To the kitten, that reprobate was a savior. So, because of one good deed, even a reprobate can be saved.

The bold part is what got me in trouble. I heard an audible gasp when I read it and smirked a little inside. Let them chew on that one for a bit. I left the Mormons soon after that. But I've always remembered that story and cannot for the life of me find it now. Maybe it rings a bell for someone?


Video is a bit shaky, but just listen to the story - it's quite good :biggrin2:

p.s. Sorry I cannot answer your final question, but I thought you would like to hear this story
 

CoriSCapnSkip

Well-Known Member
Jan 16, 2015
1,735
7,765
61
There's a short story I found when I was a teen, about a kitten. I read it as part of a talent thing when I was going to the LDS church (yes, I did!). I paired it with a poem from Paul Gallico's Honorable Cat (if you haven't read that, you should). The poem went over well but the story, not so much. This was because of its representation of Heaven.

The kitten, you see, was a stray and a "reprobate" on his way home from doing reprobate things early in the morning, saw it and, on a whim, picked it up along with a bottle of milk from a nearby stoop (yes, they used to deliver milk!). He takes the kitten up to his room and feeds it the milk. Moments later, a policeman comes and arrests him for stealing the milk. He goes to jail, cursing the kitten. The kitten goes looking for him and is hit by a car (I recall the fragment; "... and a truck came around the corner, very fast...). Years later, when the criminal dies, he goes to Heaven's gates. Peter tells him that if one soul can vouch for him, he won't go to Hell because how could a soul in Heaven be truly happy if they know a loved one is suffering in Hell? They wait... OMG, I'm getting teary writing this... and, just as the man is turning to go, the kitten comes marching to the gate, "his tail held high like a banner." To the kitten, that reprobate was a savior. So, because of one good deed, even a reprobate can be saved.

The bold part is what got me in trouble. I heard an audible gasp when I read it and smirked a little inside. Let them chew on that one for a bit. I left the Mormons soon after that. But I've always remembered that story and cannot for the life of me find it now. Maybe it rings a bell for someone?

Your LDS friends would doubtless much prefer a joke of my dad's. (He was an ordained minister and told this in church.) Al Capone arrived at the gates of Heaven and demanded admission. He was met with some version of, "Are you kidding?" from St. Peter. Capone began to rant that they had to let him in because he had done a good deed and anyone who had a good deed to his credit must be let into Heaven. "What good deed did you ever do?" "One time in Chicago, when I was drunk, I gave a beggar three cents." St. Peter had to consult over this with an entity above him in authority, (in some versions it's Angel Gabriel, in others Archangel Michael--pretty sure Dad used Gabriel--) asking what he should do, to which the authority replied, "Give him his three cents back and tell him to go to Hell."

Please try the following website with your story inquiry. Once you register, be sure you post in the Booksleuth Forum, not the General Forum. http://forums.abebooks.com/discussions/AbeBookscom_BookSleuthreg/abesleuthcom?
 

Tery

Say hello to my fishy buddy
Moderator
Apr 12, 2006
15,304
44,712
Bremerton, Washington, United States
Your LDS friends would doubtless much prefer a joke of my dad's. (He was an ordained minister and told this in church.) Al Capone arrived at the gates of Heaven and demanded admission. He was met with some version of, "Are you kidding?" from St. Peter. Capone began to rant that they had to let him in because he had done a good deed and anyone who had a good deed to his credit must be let into Heaven. "What good deed did you ever do?" "One time in Chicago, when I was drunk, I gave a beggar three cents." St. Peter had to consult over this with an entity above him in authority, (in some versions it's Angel Gabriel, in others Archangel Michael--pretty sure Dad used Gabriel--) asking what he should do, to which the authority replied, "Give him his three cents back and tell him to go to Hell."

Please try the following website with your story inquiry. Once you register, be sure you post in the Booksleuth Forum, not the General Forum. http://forums.abebooks.com/discussions/AbeBookscom_BookSleuthreg/abesleuthcom?

That's a GREAT joke! :lol:

Thanks for the lead.... :)