Are musicians our modern day philosophers?

  • This message board permanently closed on June 30th, 2020 at 4PM EDT and is no longer accepting new members.

DiO'Bolic

Not completely obtuse
Nov 14, 2013
22,864
129,998
Poconos, PA
Philosophy is characterized as the study of general and fundamental problems concerning matters such as existence, knowledge, values, reason, mind, and language. Who today, other than rock musicians, get these concepts of thought across to the masses? Is musical artistic statement not today’s modern philosophy? Music influences our formative years and often serves a backdoor guide through our journey through life.

Will history consider our generation’s philosophers to be a select group of young musician/poets who deliver their visions of existence and being in song? Hundreds of years from now will college students be learning in class about our generation's life situations and theory, usually portrayed in the form of hope, delivered by the likes of John Lennon and George Harrison of the Beatles, Bob Dylan, Cat Stevens, Pete Townshend of The Who, Bruce Springsteen, Roger Waters of Pink Floyd, Bono of U2, and Michael Stipes of R.E.M.?

(A lucid, non-dumba$$, post... There must be something wrong with me today. :))
 

GNTLGNT

The idiot is IN
Jun 15, 2007
87,651
358,754
63
Cambridge, Ohio
Philosophy is characterized as the study of general and fundamental problems concerning matters such as existence, knowledge, values, reason, mind, and language. Who today, other than rock musicians, get these concepts of thought across to the masses? Is musical artistic statement not today’s modern philosophy? Music influences our formative years and often serves a backdoor guide through our journey through life.

Will history consider our generation’s philosophers to be a select group of young musician/poets who deliver their visions of existence and being in song? Hundreds of years from now will college students be learning in class about our generation's life situations and theory, usually portrayed in the form of hope, delivered by the likes of John Lennon and George Harrison of the Beatles, Bob Dylan, Cat Stevens, Pete Townshend of The Who, Bruce Springsteen, Roger Waters of Pink Floyd, Bono of U2, and Michael Stipes of R.E.M.?

(A lucid, non-dumba$$, post... There must be something wrong with me today. :))
....I fully agree, and it's not a modern phenomenon....songwriters have long scripted the soundtrack of our lives.....looking back, looking ahead and looking inward-all the while stirring the stew of our emotions....music delivers viscerally, whereas philosophers notions spoken or written can't hold a proverbial candle to an Arlo Guhtrie or even an Eminem....
 

DiO'Bolic

Not completely obtuse
Nov 14, 2013
22,864
129,998
Poconos, PA
....I fully agree, and it's not a modern phenomenon....songwriters have long scripted the soundtrack of our lives.....looking back, looking ahead and looking inward-all the while stirring the stew of our emotions....music delivers viscerally, whereas philosophers notions spoken or written can't hold a proverbial candle to an Arlo Guhtrie or even an Eminem....
I was with you up to Eminem. :)
 

kingricefan

All-being, keeper of Space, Time & Dimension.
Jul 11, 2006
30,011
127,446
Spokane, WA
Nuff said:

"Gold"

There's a mountain & it's mighty high
You cannot see the top unless you fly
And there's a molehill of proven ground
There ain't no where 2 go if you hang around

Everybody wants 2 sell what's already been sold
Everybody wants 2 tell what's already been told
What's the use of money if you ain't gonna break the mold?
Even at the center of fire there is cold
All that glitters ain't gold
All that glitters ain't gold, mmm

There's an ocean of despair
There are people livin' there
They're unhappy each and every day
But hell is not fashion so what you tryin' 2 say?

Everybody wants 2 sell what's already been sold
Everybody wants 2 tell what's already been told
What's the use of money if you ain't gonna break the mold?
Even at the center of fire there is cold
All that glitters ain't gold, no no
All that glitters ain't gold, no no

There's a lady, 99 years old
If she led a good life, heaven takes her soul
Now that's a theory and if you don't wanna know
Step aside and make a way 4 those who want 2 go

Everybody wants 2 sell what's already been sold (Sold)
Everybody wants 2 tell what's already been told (Told)
What's the use of bein' young if you ain't gonna get old? (Old)
Even at the center of fire there is cold (Cold)
All that glitters (glitters) ain't gold, no no no no no
All that glitters ain't gold
Alright

All that glitters, all that glitters, all that glitters.. ain't gold

Na na na na na na na (Gold [x4])
Na na na na na na na (Gold [x4])
Gold, gold, gold
All that glitters ain't gold, gold, gold
All that glitters ain't gold, gold, gold (Na na na na na na na)
All that glitters ain't gold, gold, gold (Na na na na na na na)
All that glitters ain't gold, oh
Oh yeah
1 2.. 1 2 3, let's go!

(Na na na na na na na) [repeat]

You are now an official member of the New Power Generation
Welcome 2 The Dawn

All that glitters ain't gold (Gold) [repeat & loop]
 

shaitan

Meat popsicle
Dec 26, 2014
962
4,203
47
NY
Believe it or not, I see poetry, both perverse and real, in songs by a band like Slayer, or Megadeth , or Metallica ...
Absolutely. So many songs with great lyrics going through my mind right now - "Sad But True," "The Unforgiven," "Nothing Else Matters," "Skeletons Of Society," "Bitter Peace" Damn, that list is so long. The lyrics are as philosophical as it can possibly get.

So close, no matter how far
Couldn't be much more from the heart
Forever trusting who we are
And nothing else matters

Never opened myself this way
Life is ours, we live it our way
All these words I don't just say
And nothing else matters

Trust I seek and I find in you
Every day for us something new
Open mind for a different view
And nothing else matters

Never cared for what they do
Never cared for what they know
But I know
 

Ebdim9th

Dressing the Gothic interval in tritones
Jul 1, 2009
6,137
22,104
Billy Joel describes relationships and life from a well-thought-out perspective ....Even "Always A Woman To Me" causes me to evaluate just what comprises a connection on a profound level between two people ... he expresses it well outside the cliches of 'lurve song' territory ...
 

Nomik

Carry on
Jun 19, 2016
3,973
22,555
48
Derry, NH
Philosophy is characterized as the study of general and fundamental problems concerning matters such as existence, knowledge, values, reason, mind, and language. Who today, other than rock musicians, get these concepts of thought across to the masses? Is musical artistic statement not today’s modern philosophy? Music influences our formative years and often serves a backdoor guide through our journey through life.

Will history consider our generation’s philosophers to be a select group of young musician/poets who deliver their visions of existence and being in song? Hundreds of years from now will college students be learning in class about our generation's life situations and theory, usually portrayed in the form of hope, delivered by the likes of John Lennon and George Harrison of the Beatles, Bob Dylan, Cat Stevens, Pete Townshend of The Who, Bruce Springsteen, Roger Waters of Pink Floyd, Bono of U2, and Michael Stipes of R.E.M.?

(A lucid, non-dumba$$, post... There must be something wrong with me today. :))
That's an interesting topic; I read an article for work recently that pontificated quite profoundly on the subject. Chances are, I won't be able to find the link, rendering it irrelevant. The problem is that even the music of twenty or thirty years ago had more organic, cultural roots than it does today.
I'm not old enough to speak from experience, but careful observation of history leads me to believe that there the majority of today's youth do not, now will they ever, have any musical context to connect with culturally. (This will lead up to the point that technology is creating a generation of scattered thinkers)
The week the Beatles landed in America for the first time, they were, indeed, revolutionary. American music was suffering a bit of a drought, bourne of more than a generational gap. The British Invasion marked a point in global history, pre Vietnam, post Korean conflict, Kennedy's assassination, etc. . .in other words, reality was real. If that's not the stupidest thing I've ever written I don't know what is.
I'm trying to articulate a point amidst a number of distractions so bear with me, this is only way I can.
I meant young people throughout the majority of the 20th century had more connectivity with culture and current events than most people do today. The Great Depression was etched into the minds of everyone I've ever heard discuss it. The music of that time connected people to a memory of suffering, rallying together, and facing gritty reality as a unified nation (family).
WWII - my dad, a Navy vet stationed in Okinawa, will never let me forget the upbeat, big band music that meant so much to him.
Bang- baby boomers.
They are unprecedented in sheer number, so it makes sense that they would feel a sense of entitlement and power behind the music of the sixties and seventies. They were born of war, grew up with the looming shadow of imminent communist threat, and were thrust into war again. There is no escaping the symbiotic effect of musical evolution.
The eighties were part retro; an homage to the music of twenty years before, part Nuevo, part rebellion in its own right. We had finally progressed to a point of civil tolerance as a nation. Rap, metal, punk: all in its heyday and the truly great, synergistic combinations of chord work and lyric are Pink Floyd, U2, Zeppelin. . (I'm not naming them all. . . Bruce and who else? Prince evidentially?) the rest of it has merit, but can easily be pigeonholed into an obsolete genre.
Enter Gen X. Here we are with the great grunge movement, launching unforgettable mediocrity and putting the Pacific Northwest on the map of musical history. I remember the first time I heard Tori Amos and Lorena McKennit in college. Everyone else was listening to Peter Gabriel and intent owning a Volkswagen (something). By grad school, I had attended two Tori concerts, a Greenday concert (where I tried crowdsurfing for the first time) two by Primus(where I accidentally got squished by a crowd pushing into a mosh pit) one Candlebox, and a Celine Dion post titanic extravaganza.
Today, young people have so much access to technology that they are not able to immerse themselves into any one subject long enough to understand it. They have very little frame of reference for what life was like. Part of how we begin to appreciate music is socially. I don't think that earbuds and individually held communication devices offer quite the same experience as does singing along with the car radio cranked up, gas pedal down, all your friends on the same wrong note, giggling hysterically. "Every now and then I fall apart" and the parts where no one knows the lyrics so you fill it in with what you think it is, memorializing the wrong lyric. .or the infamous "mixing up the lines" fiascos : "life is a mystery, everyone must call my name? :snicker:" that still makes me laugh.
I think I've offered a meandering and somewhat historically inaccurate reply!
:thumbs_up:
That's not where I meant to go with that. I really wanted to delve into Imagine, and the ideology of communi . . .the commons. (I'm growing a tiny filter!)
I think this is a good stopping point because I doubt anyone can hang on to my train of thought this long.
 
Last edited: