It took three re-reads.

  • New to the board or trying to figure out how something works here? Check out the User Guide.
  • New 2019 Hours: The message board is closed between the hours of 4pm ET Thursday and 8:30am ET Tuesday.

    As always, the Board will be open to read and those who have those privileges can still send private messages and post to Profiles.

rudiroo

Well-Known Member
May 20, 2008
474
1,892
London, England
I've read Duma Key multiple times and have always liked it, but never *loved* it like most. This time is different-- every passage, every phrase... is hitting me. Funny how time changes our perception (or so Wireman says). ;)
Ain't that the truth.
Technically, every time we re-read a book, we're reading it for the first time.
The words on the paper are fixed and constant, but we're whirling and hurling around.
That's the argument I use when friends and family tease me about reading a book for the 20th time.

Duma Key is complex and rewarding and substantial.
We can't *love* every book, even if we want to - we'd never get any sleep:hammer:
 

Dana Jean

Moderator
Moderator
Apr 11, 2006
49,062
209,916
Thornfield
Ain't that the truth.
Technically, every time we re-read a book, we're reading it for the first time.
The words on the paper are fixed and constant, but we're whirling and hurling around.
That's the argument I use when friends and family tease me about reading a book for the 20th time.

Duma Key is complex and rewarding and substantial.
We can't *love* every book, even if we want to - we'd never get any sleep:hammer:
You're right. When I read a book over, it's like reading it new in some ways. A lot depends on age and life lessons I've learned along the way. Experiences that have happened to me since first reading the book. I can view a book totally different that I read in my 20s and now read in my later age. That's why I will read Grapes of Wrath again someday. Maybe I'll appreciate these banjo pickin' idiots now.
 

bobledrew

Inveterate yammerer
May 13, 2010
2,782
1,924
Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
Ain't that the truth.
Technically, every time we re-read a book, we're reading it for the first time.
The words on the paper are fixed and constant, but we're whirling and hurling around.
That's the argument I use when friends and family tease me about reading a book for the 20th time.

Duma Key is complex and rewarding and substantial.
We can't *love* every book, even if we want to - we'd never get any sleep:hammer:
I think Rudiroo is right on: The book is the book. It's what we BRING to the book that changes. That's why some books have a time they should be read, and some books just keep giving up more treasure with every read, like Roland's grow-bag.
 

Doc Creed

Well-Known Member
Nov 18, 2015
16,422
77,184
42
United States
I've read Duma Key multiple times and have always liked it, but never *loved* it like most. This time is different-- every passage, every phrase... is hitting me. Funny how time changes our perception (or so Wireman says). ;)
What do you think about a stage play for this one? I keep envisioning a spare set, mood lighting, wave-sounds and sliding backdrops like one would find in plays like A Streetcar Named Desire. There is a lot of great dialogue and character backstories that I think would work for the stage. The actor playing Edgar would simply hide his right arm in a sling under his shirt. It wouldn't be too expensive if done properly, just a thought.
Of course, a miniseries on Netflix would be nice, too.
 

Wab

Well-Known Member
Oct 29, 2017
86
309
What do you think about a stage play for this one? I keep envisioning a spare set, mood lighting, wave-sounds and sliding backdrops like one would find in plays like A Streetcar Named Desire. There is a lot of great dialogue and character backstories that I think would work for the stage. The actor playing Edgar would simply hide his right arm in a sling under his shirt. It wouldn't be too expensive if done properly, just a thought.
Of course, a miniseries on Netflix would be nice, too.
Even better if they hire a one-armed actor to play Edgar.
 

William8675309

Well-Known Member
Mar 9, 2018
79
331
51
I keep waiting for this one to pop up at my local thrift store in hardcover, they have Jimmy Buffett's "salty piece of land" and the spine of the dust jacket always fools me into thinking its Duma Key. :(
 
The Institute - Coming September 10th, 2019