Potted comments

  • New to the board or trying to figure out how something works here? Check out the User Guide.
  • The message board is open 8:30am ET Tuesdays to 4pm ET Thursdays. Posts cannot be made outside of board hours.

    As always, the Board will be open to read and those who have those privileges can still send private messages and post to Profiles.

Neil W

Well-Known Member
May 27, 2008
1,203
2,592
Isle of Wight UK
I was trying to get my thoughts about each book distilled into as few words as possible. Feel free to comment, disagree, andd to, offer alternatives ettc.


Carrie - A solid first published effort.
Salem’s Lot - Scary vampire tale.
The Shining - The horror novel as Literature: brilliantly structured and told.
Rage - Prescient, and the more horrifying for it.
Night Shift - Short stories, more hits than misses.
The Stand - The horror novel as Epic. A wonderfully satisfying read.
The Long Walk - Simple concept, brilliant story.
The Dead Zone - Sci-fi horror. Pleasing but sad.
Firestarter - More sci-fi horror. Action-packed with some great set pieces.
Roadwork - forgettable.
Cujo - His first claustrophobia horror novel. Adequate.
The Running Man - Dystopic sci-fi horror. Adequate.
Rita Hayworth and Shawshank Redemption - Terrific novella, suspenseful and full of heart.
The Body - Wistful nostalgia.
The Breathing Method - Obvious, but fun.
Apt Pupil - This is why people say nasty things about SK’s thought processes.
Christine - Evil car tragedy, still works well.
Pet Sematary - One of SK’s nastier horror tales, especially if you’re a parent.
The Talisman (co-written with Peter Straub) - Enjoyable road trip in parallel worlds.
Thinner - A simple but effective suspense horror.
Skeleton Crew - A mixed bag of short stories, with one or two good ones.
It - Very enjoyable journey with a slightly disappointing destination.
The Eyes Of The Dragon - Enjoyable adventure in fantasy world.
Misery - Visceral psychological (and physical) horror.
The Tommyknockers - One of his big cast, slow build books.
The Dark Half - Enjoyable suspense horror (but the background is better still!)
The Langoliers - Airport-based horror/suspense: very enjoyable.
Secret Window, Secret Garden - Madness, or something worse? The horror story as mystery.
The Library Policeman - A pleasing notion, rather forgettably executed.
The Sun Dog - Another nice idea not closely embraced by memory.
Needful Things - Big cast again, but some geuine nastiness going on.
Dolores Claiborne - Excellent character-based real-life horror.
Gerald’s Game - Simple idea, perhaps not quite enough to sustain a full novel.
Nightmares And Dreamscapes - Short stories, a good collection.
Insomnia - Fantasy meets nightmare. I really enjoyed this one.
Rose Madder - Rather forgettable real-life horror.
The Green Mile - Excellent gentle horror.
Desperation - A rather obvious monster.
The Regulators - Intriguing and offbeat.
Bag of Bones - Familiar ground, but well told.
The Girl Who Loved Tom Gordon - An oddity, but affecting and effective.
Low Men In Yellow Coats - Excellent story about childhood and friendship.
Hearts In Atlantis - A study of compulsion.
Blind Willie - Mildy touching but a little inconsequential.
Why We’re In Vietnam - Forgettable novella.
Dreamcatcher - A promising idea, but the ball got dropped.
Black House (co-written with Peter Straub) - A good sequel to The Talisman, but stylistically difficult to get started.
Everything’s Eventual - Short stories, fairly forgettable.
From a Buick 8 - Weird car tales which don’t stick in the memory.
The Colorado Kid - A slight piece, but enjoyably out of the ordinary.
Cell - OK, but a bit impersonal.
Lisey's Story - Rewarding, but not the easiest.
Blaze - Atmospheric and sad.
Duma Key - Very good supernatural horror with heart.
Just After Sunset - short stories, I think I enjoyed them but can’t really remember.
Under The Dome - Another big cast novel, an enjoyable journey with a so-so destination.
Blockade Billy -Short, nasty and effective.
1922 - Harsh and gripping.
Big Driver - Real-life horror. Good.
Fair Extension - Strong idea, well done.
A Good Marriage - Another effectively nasty piece.
11/22/63 - Superb novel: emotional and well worked out.
Joyland - Delightful short novel.
Dr Sleep - A welcome and worthy sequel.
Mr Mercedes - A nicely done procedural crime thriller.
 
The Dark Tower 1: The Gunslinger - Difficult to get into.
The Dark Tower 2: The Drawing of the Three - Completely different: excellent.
The Dark Tower 3: The Waste Lands - Another change of gears: also excellent.
The Dark Tower 4: Wizard and Glass - I didn’t care for the extensive flashback sequences.
The Dark Tower: The Wind Through The Keyhole - Very enjoyable tall tales.
The Dark Tower 5: Wolves Of The Calla - Probably my favourite DT novel.
The Dark Tower 6: Song Of Susannah - Dark moments for our travellers: but transitional and therefore less effective.
The Dark Tower 7: The Dark Tower - A very good climax, with much emotion.
 

Shasta

On his shell he holds the earth.
I can get them down to one word for you, based on what you wrote. One is, after all, the fewest possible.

Carrie - solid
Salem’s Lot - Scary
The Shining - brilliant
Rage - Prescient
Night Shift - hits
The Stand - satisfying
The Long Walk - brilliant
The Dead Zone - Pleasing
Firestarter - great
Roadwork - forgettable.
Cujo - Adequate.
The Running Man - Adequate.
Rita Hayworth and Shawshank Redemption - Terrific
The Body - Wistful
The Breathing Method - Obvious
Apt Pupil - nasty
Christine - Evil
Pet Sematary - nasty
The Talisman (co-written with Peter Straub) - Enjoyable
Thinner - effective
Skeleton Crew - mixed
It - enjoyable
The Eyes Of The Dragon - Enjoyable
Misery - Visceral
The Tommyknockers - slow
The Dark Half - Enjoyable
The Langoliers - enjoyable.
Secret Window, Secret Garden -mystery.
The Library Policeman -pleasing
The Sun Dog - nice
Needful Things - nasty
Dolores Claiborne - Excellent
Gerald’s Game - Simple
Nightmares And Dreamscapes -good
Insomnia - Fantasy
Rose Madder - forgettable
The Green Mile - Excellent
Desperation - obvious
The Regulators - Intriguing
Bag of Bones - Familiar
The Girl Who Loved Tom Gordon - oddity
Low Men In Yellow Coats - Excellent
Hearts In Atlantis - compulsion.
Blind Willie - inconsequential.
Why We’re In Vietnam - Forgettable
Dreamcatcher - promising
Black House (co-written with Peter Straub) - good
Everything’s Eventual - forgettable.
From a Buick 8 - Weird
The Colorado Kid - enjoyable
Cell - impersonal.
Lisey's Story - Rewarding
Blaze - Atmospheric
Duma Key - good
Just After Sunset - enjoyable
Under The Dome - enjoyable
Blockade Billy -effective.
1922 - Harsh
Big Driver - Good.
Fair Extension - Strong
A Good Marriage -effective
11/22/63 - emotional
Joyland - Delightful
Dr Sleep - worthy
Mr Mercedes - procedural

The Dark Tower 1: The Gunslinger - Difficult
The Dark Tower 2: The Drawing of the Three - excellent.
The Dark Tower 3: The Waste Lands - excellent.
The Dark Tower 4: Wizard and Glass - extensive
The Dark Tower: The Wind Through The Keyhole -enjoyable
The Dark Tower 5: Wolves Of The Calla - favourite
The Dark Tower 6: Song Of Susannah - transitional
The Dark Tower 7: The Dark Tower - emotion.


(Please note that these are definitely not my opinions. We seem to disagree on pretty much all of them!)
 
If It Bleeds - New Collection Coming 5/5/20 The Institute - Available Now Flight or Fright - Now Available in Trade Paperback!