Fruitcake and Eggnog. Yay or Nay?

  • This message board permanently closed on June 30th, 2020 at 4PM EDT and is no longer accepting new members.

AnnaMarie

Well-Known Member
Feb 16, 2012
7,068
29,564
Other
Grandma's wasn't like much like a traditional fruitcake. We usually ate it a couple of days after she baked it.
It has a more cake like texture than traditional fruitcake.
She stored hers on a plate, on the kitchen table, with the baking pan as a cover.

I make at least three bread-sized loaves of each cake. Depends whether I remember to cut everything in half. No way am I serving all that at once.
 

Sundrop

Sunny the Great & Wonderful
Jun 12, 2008
28,520
156,619
I make at least three bread-sized loaves of each cake. Depends whether I remember to cut everything in half. No way am I serving all that at once.
That's a lot of fruitcake! I don't blame you.
Grandma made hers in a large tube pan. We always brought half of it home with us on Christmas Eve, and nibbled on it until the new year.
 

Sundrop

Sunny the Great & Wonderful
Jun 12, 2008
28,520
156,619
I just looked for my copy of Grandma's recipe.......It's gone. I sure hope my Mom has a copy of it, otherwise I'm going to have to break down and call my dad to get it. I really don't want to call him.
 

Sundrop

Sunny the Great & Wonderful
Jun 12, 2008
28,520
156,619
Check in the fridge. You never know what might be hiding in there.......
The fridge is for science experiments only......

I know you're gonna laugh, but I always kept Grandma's Pecan Cake recipe in the cabinet, under the sugar container. It's the only recipe that isn't kept in the box with the rest of them. I don't know why I've done this, but I always have. I cleaned out the cabinet last week, and tossed out all the expired flavorings, seasonings, etc.....but I don't remember moving that recipe.
 

Out of Order

Sign of the Times
Feb 9, 2011
29,007
162,154
New Hampster
The fridge is for science experiments only......

I know you're gonna laugh, but I always kept Grandma's Pecan Cake recipe in the cabinet, under the sugar container. It's the only recipe that isn't kept in the box with the rest of them. I don't know why I've done this, but I always have. I cleaned out the cabinet last week, and tossed out all the expired flavorings, seasonings, etc.....but I don't remember moving that recipe.

Did you move the recipe after "remodeling" the wine rack by any chance?
 

TheRedQueen

And Crazy Housewife
Dec 3, 2014
1,346
8,164
36
Fernley, NV.
I tried my hand at making a "fruitcake" last year, and had dubious results.

I took a box of spice cake mix, and instead of using the candied fruit, (I agree that that stuff is nasty) I used simple dried fruit. Golden raisins and cranberries, mostly. And then canned pineapple pieces, and I think I used fresh blackberries. (Now I'm wondering if fresh raspberries would be good too) And I like maraschino cherries, so I cut some in half to mix in the batter. Once the cake was cooled and put into its own dish, I put the rest of the halved maraschino cherries on top, gathered up whatever bits of cake that stuck to the baking pan, and crumbled that up on top of the cherries. Then I used honey, the juice from the pineapples, and a bit of sweetened condensed milk to make the "frosting". I drizzled the different liquids all over the top of the cake, letting them soak in. I put several coats of this on, then popped it in the fridge to set. It turned out tasting pretty darned good, it's a recipe you can really play with, and it's easy to make.

I just don't know if it qualifies as real fruitcake. Maybe fruitcake's nutless cousin?



That just doesn't sound right...
 

Moderator

Ms. Mod
Administrator
Jul 10, 2006
52,243
157,324
Maine
I tried my hand at making a "fruitcake" last year, and had dubious results.

I took a box of spice cake mix, and instead of using the candied fruit, (I agree that that stuff is nasty) I used simple dried fruit. Golden raisins and cranberries, mostly. And then canned pineapple pieces, and I think I used fresh blackberries. (Now I'm wondering if fresh raspberries would be good too) And I like maraschino cherries, so I cut some in half to mix in the batter. Once the cake was cooled and put into its own dish, I put the rest of the halved maraschino cherries on top, gathered up whatever bits of cake that stuck to the baking pan, and crumbled that up on top of the cherries. Then I used honey, the juice from the pineapples, and a bit of sweetened condensed milk to make the "frosting". I drizzled the different liquids all over the top of the cake, letting them soak in. I put several coats of this on, then popped it in the fridge to set. It turned out tasting pretty darned good, it's a recipe you can really play with, and it's easy to make.

I just don't know if it qualifies as real fruitcake. Maybe fruitcake's nutless cousin?



That just doesn't sound right...
That sounds delicious and would turn my 10 lb holiday weight gain into 20 if I had any of it around! :smile:
 

Haunted

This is my favorite place
Mar 26, 2008
17,059
29,421
The woods are lovely dark and deep
They are really expensive to make. More so for me because some of the ingredients are difficult to find peanut/nut free, and then I have to pay whatever they ask.
I usually cut up my fruit one day and mix and bake it the next because, yes, it is time consuming.

My recipe has no nuts and no rum. And I do not out any kind of icing on it.
Your recipe sounds just about right, I don't think nuts or booze belong in a cake. Yech. Enough sweetness within warrants no outside dressing IMH0
 

Haunted

This is my favorite place
Mar 26, 2008
17,059
29,421
The woods are lovely dark and deep
I tried my hand at making a "fruitcake" last year, and had dubious results.

I took a box of spice cake mix, and instead of using the candied fruit, (I agree that that stuff is nasty) I used simple dried fruit. Golden raisins and cranberries, mostly. And then canned pineapple pieces, and I think I used fresh blackberries. (Now I'm wondering if fresh raspberries would be good too) And I like maraschino cherries, so I cut some in half to mix in the batter. Once the cake was cooled and put into its own dish, I put the rest of the halved maraschino cherries on top, gathered up whatever bits of cake that stuck to the baking pan, and crumbled that up on top of the cherries. Then I used honey, the juice from the pineapples, and a bit of sweetened condensed milk to make the "frosting". I drizzled the different liquids all over the top of the cake, letting them soak in. I put several coats of this on, then popped it in the fridge to set. It turned out tasting pretty darned good, it's a recipe you can really play with, and it's easy to make.

I just don't know if it qualifies as real fruitcake. Maybe fruitcake's nutless cousin?



That just doesn't sound right...
WOW WOW WOW maybe not traditional but it sounds like a real treat!
 

Haunted

This is my favorite place
Mar 26, 2008
17,059
29,421
The woods are lovely dark and deep
I like my home made fruit cake. I haven't been able to eat any store bought since developing my allergies. People put nuts in them. (Pre-allergies I never liked nuts in my fruit cake.)

When I make them, it's very expensive because I have both my Mom's recipes and I have to make both because I like the dark and my husband likes the light.

Personal story, skip if you want.
My mom passed away in 1988. About 12 years later I finally tried making her fruit cake. It turned out fabulous. I'm not big on socializing with my siblings, but that year I invited everyone over during the holidays. I put out a plate of cookies, which included the fruit cake, and I watched. Everyone always likes my cookies because they are what we grew up on.

My brother took a piece of fruit cake, and took a bite. Then he closed his eyes, and just had the most amazing look on his face. He picked up the plate and insisted our other brother and sister try it. One said "No, I only like mom's fruitcake" eventually he tried it.

Everyone agreed, it was like having mom back for the holiday.

I don't like egg nog but will have a tiny bit if the family is all drinking it.



I was going to put a John Pinette clip....but all the ones with "nay nay" also have swear words.
Your brothers and sister recognized your Mom in something you made? What an accomplishment! Wow, you must have gotten chills, I know I did reading your story. Thanks for passing it on.
 

DiO'Bolic

Not completely obtuse
Nov 14, 2013
22,864
129,998
Poconos, PA
TOP 10 USES FOR HOLIDAY FRUITCAKES
10. Use slices to balance that wobbly kitchen table.
9. Use instead of sand bags during El Nino.
8. Send to U.S. Air Force, and drop them out of bombers.
7. Use as railroad ties.
6. Use as speed bumps to foil the neighborhood drag racers.
5. Collect ten and use them as bowling pins.
4. Use instead of cement shoes.
3. Save for next summer's garage sale.
2. Use slices in next skeet-shooting competition.
1. Best gift for someone you really hate.


I must admit... I do like the traditional French Eggnog:
Four egg yolks, 2 teaspoons of sugar, half-gallon of eggnog ice cream, and ten jiggers of cognac in a tall, warm lass.

:)
 

GNTLGNT

The idiot is IN
Jun 15, 2007
87,651
358,754
62
Cambridge, Ohio
I'm in the minority here I guess. I like both. In fact, I usually eat a little fruit cake, tuck it in my cheek and then swill a little rum egg nog. My Brando impersonation is the hit of the party.
ds_godfather_paramount_540x386.jpg