Well, i'm pretty well scholed in at least Doyles Holmes stuff. Have read all of it even if i don't remember them all. I still think Holmes lost alot of his sparkle in the latter collections. Will be interesting to see what Simmons made out of him. Saw a relatively recent movie (sherlock?) that was, i thought, horrible but it was a success so what do i know, right?I've read it. I'm not a big Holmes fan, so I didn't care that much for it. You really have to have read the Holmes stories before reading this one. It's been just too long for me to remember much about Doyles' works.
John