IDRIS ELBA, YES YES YES

  • This message board permanently closed on June 30th, 2020 at 4PM EDT and is no longer accepting new members.

Dana Jean

Dirty Pirate Hooker, The Return
Moderator
Apr 11, 2006
53,634
236,697
The High Seas
That's not fair.

King should care about my opinion (which agrees with Hazenko) as much as he should care about the opinion of any other fans of his books. He was cruder than me... but basically same opinion as
I.

I may look for a troll avatar. ;;D



King's choice. "Honky MaFa"
Well, now. Honky MaFa is totally acceptable.
 

GNTLGNT

The idiot is IN
Jun 15, 2007
87,651
358,754
59
Cambridge, Ohio
That's not fair.

King should care about my opinion (which agrees with Hazenko) as much as he should care about the opinion of any other fans of his books. He was cruder than me... but basically same opinion as
I.

I may look for a troll avatar. ;;D



King's choice. "Honky MaFa"
...fair or not doesn't matter to me in this case...it was the tone that set me off...don't come into new territory without at least a modicum of respect for the host....YOU handle yourself politely when you dissent....and I mean that with respect, you don't troll....
 

Robert Gray

Well-Known Member
Stephen King is the author of the BOOKS. He didn't write the screen play. He, like most of us, would love to see a great movie get made. His input, however, is limited. I don't know why everyone assumes that authors have veto rights or direct control. That has rarely (if ever) happened. If the film stinks, it can never take anything away from the books. We will always have those. We have the Taleslinger to thank for that. If/when the time comes to rage, put the blame where it belongs, i.e. the Studio, Producers, and Director.
 

AnnaMarie

Well-Known Member
Feb 16, 2012
7,068
29,564
Other
Stephen King is the author of the BOOKS. He didn't write the screen play. He, like most of us, would love to see a great movie get made. His input, however, is limited. I don't know why everyone assumes that authors have veto rights or direct control. That has rarely (if ever) happened. If the film stinks, it can never take anything away from the books. We will always have those. We have the Taleslinger to thank for that. If/when the time comes to rage, put the blame where it belongs, i.e. the Studio, Producers, and Director.

First of all, I do think he could have refused to allow. Maybe I'm wrong. But doesn't matter because....it's his work and his choice.

But, I'm not sure I 100% agree it wouldn't take anything away from the books. If I were to watch the movie, it could be bad enough that it would affect my enjoyment of rereading the books. Clan of the Cave Bear did that. It was many years before I could reread it.
 

Robert Gray

Well-Known Member
But, I'm not sure I 100% agree it wouldn't take anything away from the books. If I were to watch the movie, it could be bad enough that it would affect my enjoyment of rereading the books. Clan of the Cave Bear did that. It was many years before I could reread it.

Then do as I plan on doing; don't go see it until you have heard enough to know it is safe (and not a waste of your money). Movies are entirely self-inflicted wounds. :) We live in a day and age information and movie studios can't keep secrets even if they wanted to do so. Rotten Tomatoes will have told us if this thing is any good by giving us a average review of both the critics and audience. I've found that average to be fairly accurate on the whole. More to the point, you have this wonderful place provided for us to talk about all things King (and everything else too). I have no doubt there will be more than enough fans of the books going to tell us the skinny. All that aside, think about Star Wars and how dreadful those pre-equals were. I just deleted them from my mind. They don't exist. Easy as that. :D The same can be done for any movie adaptation.
 

AnnaMarie

Well-Known Member
Feb 16, 2012
7,068
29,564
Other
Then do as I plan on doing; don't go see it until you have heard enough to know it is safe (and not a waste of your money). Movies are entirely self-inflicted wounds. :) We live in a day and age information and movie studios can't keep secrets even if they wanted to do so. Rotten Tomatoes will have told us if this thing is any good by giving us a average review of both the critics and audience. I've found that average to be fairly accurate on the whole. More to the point, you have this wonderful place provided for us to talk about all things King (and everything else too). I have no doubt there will be more than enough fans of the books going to tell us the skinny. All that aside, think about Star Wars and how dreadful those pre-equals were. I just deleted them from my mind. They don't exist. Easy as that. :D The same can be done for any movie adaptation.

I have no intention of seeing this movie.

I didn't hate the Star Wars prequels. I even like Jar Jar. Makes my son cringe whenever I say that. But that COTCB movie, I could not just delete from my mind. And it was my comfort book. So dog eared it literally fell apart. But I had to avoid it for years. Now...only one scene remains in my mind and it wasn't in the book at all. so...I will not see DT.
 

Rockym

Well-Known Member
Feb 11, 2012
77
236
I have no intention of seeing this movie.

I didn't hate the Star Wars prequels. I even like Jar Jar. Makes my son cringe whenever I say that. But that COTCB movie, I could not just delete from my mind. And it was my comfort book. So dog eared it literally fell apart. But I had to avoid it for years. Now...only one scene remains in my mind and it wasn't in the book at all. so...I will not see DT.

Yeah me neither. My hype for this movie was instantly killed when I saw that Idris was cast as Roland. Anyone who has read the books can clearly see he is white. Really getting sick and tired of Hollywood race changing long time established characters.
 

Ebdim9th

Dressing the Gothic interval in tritones
Jul 1, 2009
6,137
22,104
Then do as I plan on doing; don't go see it until you have heard enough to know it is safe (and not a waste of your money). Movies are entirely self-inflicted wounds. :) We live in a day and age information and movie studios can't keep secrets even if they wanted to do so. Rotten Tomatoes will have told us if this thing is any good by giving us a average review of both the critics and audience. I've found that average to be fairly accurate on the whole. More to the point, you have this wonderful place provided for us to talk about all things King (and everything else too). I have no doubt there will be more than enough fans of the books going to tell us the skinny. All that aside, think about Star Wars and how dreadful those pre-equals were. I just deleted them from my mind. They don't exist. Easy as that. :D The same can be done for any movie adaptation.


I'm still waiting for a LOST/ Star Wars crossover movie ....... J.J. Abrams directing and Damon Lindelof screenplay-ing, of course ......
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maddie and GNTLGNT
Mar 12, 2010
6,538
29,004
Texas
Yeah me neither. My hype for this movie was instantly killed when I saw that Idris was cast as Roland. Anyone who has read the books can clearly see he is white. Really getting sick and tired of Hollywood race changing long time established characters.

Look on the bright side :) If BBC had been involved with the movie, a female could have been cast as Roland (is thinking Doctor Who). Apart from the skin color, Idris looks quite a bit how I imagined Roland to look.

Actually, after thinking about it, a female Roland might be interesting lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maddie and GNTLGNT

Zone D Dad

Well-Known Member
Apr 17, 2017
359
1,829
Chicago Suburbs
I think it's an interesting choice for Elba to play Roland. I like him, so I certainly don't have a problem with it. I probably have a bigger issue with the Man In Black casting. I like Matthew Mcconaughey, but he just doesn't seem right to me for that role. I hope I'm wrong - I often am. I didn't think Tom Cruise could do Interview with a Vampire either and that turned out just fine.

I have to admit that I've never been excited about a DT adaptation period, although the trailer looks better to me than expected. I like to be reasonably open-minded.
 

recitador

Speed Reader
Sep 3, 2016
1,750
8,264
38
I think it's an interesting choice for Elba to play Roland. I like him, so I certainly don't have a problem with it. I probably have a bigger issue with the Man In Black casting. I like Matthew Mcconaughey, but he just doesn't seem right to me for that role. I hope I'm wrong - I often am. I didn't think Tom Cruise could do Interview with a Vampire either and that turned out just fine.

I have to admit that I've never been excited about a DT adaptation period, although the trailer looks better to me than expected. I like to be reasonably open-minded.

after the whole heath ledger kerfuffle regarding his casting as the joker, i try to just wait it out and see what will happen. until you see a whole movie, casting is hard to really rate. and some of the most unlikely casting has led to some really good performances.
 

Zone D Dad

Well-Known Member
Apr 17, 2017
359
1,829
Chicago Suburbs
after the whole heath ledger kerfuffle regarding his casting as the joker, i try to just wait it out and see what will happen. until you see a whole movie, casting is hard to really rate. and some of the most unlikely casting has led to some really good performances.

Totally agree. Great performances are often unexpected and casting can be a touchy thing. Except for Shelly Duvall in the Popeye movie - she was born for that role.
 

HollyGolightly

Well-Known Member
Sep 6, 2013
9,660
74,320
51
Heart of the South
I saw the movie last night but can't really say too much about it as it's still embargoed until 8 PM tonight. I think it's okay to say I didn't have a problem with either actor.
I'm so happy to hear this! I cannot wait until Friday night. I'm definitely going to see it.

I haven't read the entire thread, but I wanted to say that I absolutely love that SK allows movies to be made of his work. It's very interesting to see how others visualize the characters and settings and such. Even if he disagrees with the interpretation, allowing it to unfold is precious. Some I've liked, some I can't be bothered to watch - but at least they are out there. I'll report back after I've seen it. I wish we could all go see it together, have drinks after.