Pet Sematary Remake

  • New to the board or trying to figure out how something works here? Check out the User Guide.
  • New 2019 Hours: The message board is closed between the hours of 4pm ET Thursday and 8:30am ET Tuesday.

    As always, the Board will be open to read and those who have those privileges can still send private messages and post to Profiles.

Marty Coslaw

Well-Known Member
May 19, 2018
121
405
33
DC
I was hoping to like this remake; however, given the fact that there has only been one movie whose remake I have liked, that was a very unrealstic hope. I am not putting anyone involved in this project down, it's just that I loved everything about the original movie: the cast, the setting, that house...oh, that house!
Did you see Unearthed and Untold? It's a full-length Making Of, with really cool details about the house, and plenty of other behind-the-scenes stuff.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GNTLGNT

Marty Coslaw

Well-Known Member
May 19, 2018
121
405
33
DC
I was disappointed with the new movie. I was disappointed with a few key things:
1. Louise and Jud's relationship was very developed in the book but not at all in the new movie. In the book and in the 89 movie, they captured the father-like portrayal of Jud. The new movie depicts jud as a lonely hermit who is mildly welcomed as a neighbor.
2. I'm fine with the kid switch but the directing the audience to Gage in movie is a moot point when we know it's Ellie from the spoiler-y trailer.
3. Gage is totally a non-character in the new movie. Has no purpose other than that last shots cheap scare.
4. The ending was okay but rushed and ineffective.
5. I applaud their balls to include Zelda after the effective version in 89, but they were afraid to do anything with her than tease a few cheap scares.
6. Pascow was pointless entirely.

However, overall it's an OKAY movie. Not a memorable one.
So agree with you about Judd. He was so unremarkable in his interaction with Louis and his own personality that he served as nothing but a plot device. Pascow was given a similar treatment. You're also right about Gage/Ellie, though at the time I was actually impressed that they had done something I hadn't expected, even if it was a sort of fake-out.

The unifying aspect here, I think, is that the film gives a cursory treatment to the meatiest parts of the story: the burial ground itself and its history, Pascow's connection to Louis, Judd's relationship with Louis, the trauma of losing a child (and the guilt of feeling you could have prevented it), and most of all, the darn wendigo. The whole thing feels distanced. It would be like if Marty McFly had just watched a video of 1950's suburbia instead of being transported there--no immersion. I have to admit, though, the twist at the end was pretty good.
 

Doc Creed

Well-Known Member
Nov 18, 2015
16,661
78,824
42
United States
So agree with you about Judd. He was so unremarkable in his interaction with Louis and his own personality that he served as nothing but a plot device. Pascow was given a similar treatment. You're also right about Gage/Ellie, though at the time I was actually impressed that they had done something I hadn't expected, even if it was a sort of fake-out.

The unifying aspect here, I think, is that the film gives a cursory treatment to the meatiest parts of the story: the burial ground itself and its history, Pascow's connection to Louis, Judd's relationship with Louis, the trauma of losing a child (and the guilt of feeling you could have prevented it), and most of all, the darn wendigo. The whole thing feels distanced. It would be like if Marty McFly had just watched a video of 1950's suburbia instead of being transported there--no immersion. I have to admit, though, the twist at the end was pretty good.
:shake::clap:
 

Hill lover35

Well-Known Member
Jan 8, 2017
3,186
16,632
38
Alberta canada
And while I loved the Ramones version of the song Pet Sematary, (did the Ramones spell it Cemetery or Sematary?) I really do like the new cover. I think we've got the old school meeting new and a nice tribute to the original artists.


and the original:

yeh the new song is amazing

I think the ramones whent with sematary
 

jujuhound

Member
Nov 16, 2017
13
47
39
does any one have this on the dvd? I guess they have included an alternative ending and was just wondering what it was?
Ellie drags a still-alive Rachel to the burial ground. Louis still confronts and fights Ellie but she convinces him to help bury Rachel. Thus Louis is never stabbed, killed and reburied as we see in the regular ending. In the end, the reanimated Rachel and Ellie are shown in the house with Gage and Louis still alive. The music is more somber.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Notaro and GNTLGNT

jujuhound

Member
Nov 16, 2017
13
47
39
So agree with you about Judd. He was so unremarkable in his interaction with Louis and his own personality that he served as nothing but a plot device. Pascow was given a similar treatment. You're also right about Gage/Ellie, though at the time I was actually impressed that they had done something
The unifying aspect here, I think, is that the film gives a cursory treatment to the meatiest parts of the story: the burial ground itself and its history, Pascow's connection to Louis, Judd's relationship with Louis, the trauma of losing a child (and the guilt of feeling you could have prevented it), and most of all, the darn wendigo. The whole thing feels distanced. It would be like if Marty McFly had just watched a video of 1950's suburbia instead of being transported there--no immersion. I have to admit, though, the twist at the end was pretty good.
Good points. Same with Rachel's parents and their relationship with Louis. I need to add that leaving the Timmy Baterman story out was a wasted opportunity to establish how terrible of an idea it was to bury a person. On a positive note, a bonus feature on the physical disc has Lithgow in character as Jud narrating the Baterman story to nobody in particular.

Lastly......
A deleted scene on the disc has Jud revealing to Louis that Norma died before the events of the movie and that he buried her up there with predictable results, though Jud was only scarred and not killed.
 
The Institute - Coming September 10th, 2019 IT - Now Available in Trade Paperback! Flight or Fright - Now Available in Trade Paperback! The Outsider - Now Available in Trade Paperback!