Jack reacher

  • New to the board or trying to figure out how something works here? Check out the User Guide.
  • Hot Topics is on indefinite hiatus.

  • The message board is closed between the hours of 4pm ET Friday and 8:30am ET Monday.

    As always, the Board will be open to read and those who have those privileges can still send private messages and post to Profiles.

rudiroo

Well-Known Member
May 20, 2008
467
1,857
London, England
#6
It's not the midget Jack Reacher from the films though.
Why am I laughing? That's low*, champ1966, but it's funny (*no pun intended)!
Best not to think about the films - like a schmuck, I assumed that this was one series that would never reach the screen.

Reacher exists in my imagination - hotter than July (I'm a woman. I can't help it), as brave as Spartacus, as near to a superhero as any man could be.
When you fall for a fictional character, the writer has exceeded his job description, big time.

And what a lovely compliment from SK to Lee Child:clap:
 

rudiroo

Well-Known Member
May 20, 2008
467
1,857
London, England
#15
I have a problem with Cruise in just about any role. :highly_amused:
Could you cut him some slack in War of the Worlds(2005) and Born on the 4th of July(1989)?

WOTW was as scary as all get-out and he was a convincing regular guy.

And July made me stop and think properly about the guys who couldn't (and didn't) dodge the draft (like one of my tutors at university). Late-flourishing shame, if you will, 10 years after I went to university:facepalm_smiley:.

When the UK got into Gulf War 1.
Now it's personal, when your baby brother's older friend is out there, in the sandbox, and you're hoping and praying his buddy comes home. . .

Anyway, way off topic (sorry!).
Cruise can act, but not Reacher.
 

shaitan

Meat popsicle
Dec 26, 2014
962
4,196
41
NY
#16
No. It's not just you.
But ultimately, Mr. Child owns Reacher and he can do what he wants with him (sigh).
Gotta respect a man's property . .:indecisiveness:
I know he approved the choice and you can't argue with that. After all, Morgan Freeman played Red and Tim Robbins played a short accountant type guy with sandy blond hair and it has to be one of the best movies I've ever seen.
 

shaitan

Meat popsicle
Dec 26, 2014
962
4,196
41
NY
#17
Could you cut him some slack in War of the Worlds(2005) and Born on the 4th of July(1989)?

WOTW was as scary as all get-out and he was a convincing regular guy.

And July made me stop and think properly about the guys who couldn't (and didn't) dodge the draft (like one of my tutors at university). Late-flourishing shame, if you will, 10 years after I went to university:facepalm_smiley:.

When the UK got into Gulf War 1.
Now it's personal, when your baby brother's older friend is out there, in the sandbox, and you're hoping and praying his buddy comes home. . .

Anyway, way off topic (sorry!).
Cruise can act, but not Reacher.
In my highly subjective opinion, Tom Cruise tends to over-act and ruins a lot of movies that otherwise had a potential to be good and that includes the first Jack Reacher movie. In fact, Tom Cruise is the reason I don't want to see the second movie that just came out.
 

Tery

A homeward angel on the fly
Moderator
Apr 12, 2006
13,525
35,124
Bremerton, Washington, United States
#19
Could you cut him some slack in War of the Worlds(2005) and Born on the 4th of July(1989)?
No, not for WOTW. But I can for BOT4OJ, I guess. I actually did like him in Risky Business but then he got all full of himself real quick. I know people who have worked with him and they have stories.... I know I should be able to separate the actor from the man but I just can't. My deal, I know it. I own it.
 

rudiroo

Well-Known Member
May 20, 2008
467
1,857
London, England
#20
I know people who have worked with him and they have stories.... I know I should be able to separate the actor from the man but I just can't. My deal, I know it. I own it.
Being able to separate the actor from the (wo)man is very very difficult - when I found out a thing or two about James Stewart, via his biographer, I dumped his films.
Ditto TS Eliot - hard to like a man (even though he wrote awesome poetry)when you know he would despise you. Rinse and repeat for Philip Larkin.

I don't see your opinion as a negative - on the contrary, your opinion is an informed one (people who have worked with him).
Sad to hear that he's a . . whatever. . . but your opinion is still 100% valid .:thumbs_up:
 
We’ve created a Stephen King Library action for the 
			  Google Assistant and skill for Amazon Alexa. It'll give 
			  you a personalized reading recommendations based on your 
			  answers to a series of questions—so what are you waiting 
			  for? Find out which Stephen King book you should read 
			  next!