This message board permanently closed on June 30th at 4PM EDT and is no longer accepting new members.
I just started reading NOS4A2 yesterday. I'm very much enjoying it.
Joe's work is great, I would say that N0S4R2 is my favourite, followed by Horns and then HSB.I thought it was Joe's best book so far.
Heart Shaped Box and Horns were both great too, but this had the edge for me.
I can probably get HSB from the library - I just liked the fantasy elements and the covered bridge parts of NOS4A2 - is Heart Shaped Book similar?On another forum I visit, a lot of the folks on there seemed to think Heart Shaped Box was his best book, but I would disagree.
For me, NOS4A2 is a much better story