Christmas Cookies

  • This message board permanently closed on June 30th, 2020 at 4PM EDT and is no longer accepting new members.

Todash

Free spirit. Curly girl. Cookie eater. Proud SJW.
Aug 19, 2006
8,293
5,621
52
Kansas City
Hey ... so, I just pulled the cardboard things off the new cookie sheets, and on the back there is a recipe for salted chocolate chip cookies. It mostly looks like chocolate chip cookies with sea salt on top—not that there's anything wrong with that—but it calls for cake flour instead of all-purpose. Have any of you ever used cake flour for cookies? I mean, it's FABULOUS for cakes, but ... I feel like I might be bordering on heresy by considering using it for cookies.
 

Spideyman

Uber Member
Jul 10, 2006
46,336
195,472
79
Just north of Duma Key
Hey ... so, I just pulled the cardboard things off the new cookie sheets, and on the back there is a recipe for salted chocolate chip cookies. It mostly looks like chocolate chip cookies with sea salt on top—not that there's anything wrong with that—but it calls for cake flour instead of all-purpose. Have any of you ever used cake flour for cookies? I mean, it's FABULOUS for cakes, but ... I feel like I might be bordering on heresy by considering using it for cookies.

I would think it would make the cookie puffy and cake like in texture. Might be something different.
 

Todash

Free spirit. Curly girl. Cookie eater. Proud SJW.
Aug 19, 2006
8,293
5,621
52
Kansas City
I would think it would make the cookie puffy and cake like in texture. Might be something different.
Yeah, I'm not a big fan of cakey cookies ... I don't know. On the other hand, the taste of cake flour is so much purer and cleaner than that of all-purpose flour. It's tempting.

Oh, what the hell. I might as well try it. What's the worst that could happen? Bad cookies? O THE HORROR.
 

Sigmund

Waiting in Uber.
Jan 3, 2010
13,979
44,046
In your mirror.
Hey ... so, I just pulled the cardboard things off the new cookie sheets, and on the back there is a recipe for salted chocolate chip cookies. It mostly looks like chocolate chip cookies with sea salt on top—not that there's anything wrong with that—but it calls for cake flour instead of all-purpose. Have any of you ever used cake flour for cookies? I mean, it's FABULOUS for cakes, but ... I feel like I might be bordering on heresy by considering using it for cookies.

Try it! Try it! Try it!
 

Todash

Free spirit. Curly girl. Cookie eater. Proud SJW.
Aug 19, 2006
8,293
5,621
52
Kansas City
Try it! Try it! Try it!
I totally am! Except I don't have nearly enough butter ... could have sworn we had more, but I guess we ate it. I've got to run to the store after dinner.

Also, I actually read the recipe, and I notice it has both all-purpose AND cake flour. So ... interesting. I'm definitely trying it, as I've got a bunch of cake flour that needs to be used anyway.
 

Sigmund

Waiting in Uber.
Jan 3, 2010
13,979
44,046
In your mirror.
Molasses cookies are THE bomb.

Gluten-Free-Molasses-Cookies-4.jpg
Glass_of_milk.jpg